THE SILENCE

The past is about to catch up to a group of friends that may have accidentally killed a serial killer.

A weekend music festival in the woods featuring 1990s cover bands seems like the perfect way for Liverpudlians Matt Connolly, his live-in girlfriend, Alexandra, and their childhood friends Stuart, Chris, Nicola, and Michelle to reconnect and shake off the middle-age doldrums. The fun turns into terror when Matt awakens in the middle of night to Stuart’s screams. The group eventually catches up to Stuart, who is fighting for his life with a machete-wielding maniac. Matt’s group soon gets the upper hand, and in the end, it’s not clear who dealt the killing blow, but the stranger is undeniably dead. Despite his friends’ urging, Matt nixes calling the authorities. For some inconceivable reason, he thinks they’ll be accused of killing the man in an alcohol- and drug-fueled frenzy. They bury the guy and plan to skedaddle, but they then discover the body of a young man next to a flickering red candle. They reason that the man they buried could be the mythical (so far) killer dubbed the Candle Man who leaves behind red candles when he abducts someone. But no bodies have been found, suggesting he’s a mere urban legend. Yikes, definitely time to leave and never speak of the incident again. Flash-forward a year. Guilt has been eating at Matt, whose narrative alternates between past and present, and his friends. After one of their own supposedly jumps in front of a train, they begin finding the distinctive red candles in their homes. They suspect the man they killed may have had an accomplice who is now targeting them one by one. Unfortunately, the narrative largely consists of Matt and the gang arguing the merits of confessing versus keeping their secret, and after slogging through a glacially paced story nearly devoid of suspense, readers might find it’s too much work to get to a shock twist that isn’t fully earned.

Just watch I Know What You Did Last Summer instead.