I WAS TOLD THERE WOULD BE ROMANCE

A teen’s life goes topsy-turvy thanks to secrets, lies, and a romantic bargain with a crush.

Falencia “Fancy” Augustine is a 15-year-old Black girl of Haitian descent. Fancy doesn’t do well with change and also has issues with focusing, which have resulted in her falling behind in several classes. She generally feels like an outcast except when she’s with her best friend, Tilly Fischer. When Fancy learns that Tilly has kept secrets from her—she has a new boyfriend and was invited to the exclusive birthday party of Imani Parker, the most popular girl in school—she’s thrown off kilter. The threat of being sent to Haiti if her grades don’t improve also hangs over her head (“‘vacation Haiti’ and ‘sent-back Haiti’ are two very different things”). Anxiety attacks, fast-spreading “Voodoo witch” rumors, and impulsive decisions lead Fancy to agree to a deal with Imani: She can come to the party; she just needs to show up with a boyfriend. Fancy persuades Rahim Robinson, her crush, to fake date her in exchange for a potion. But how will she untangle this complicated web? Arnold’s multidimensional lead organically pulls readers into the story: Fancy is flawed, self-aware, and charming, and her open and direct nature and often-humorous delivery are appealing. This novel also thoughtfully explores themes of friendship, romance, identity, and body image. Most cast members are Black.

A refreshingly vulnerable and candid protagonist cements this story’s appeal.