Kirkus Reviews QR Code
WHEN THINGS GET PERSONAL by Mark Schroeder

WHEN THINGS GET PERSONAL

A Philosophical Guide to Conflict

by Mark Schroeder

Pub Date: Oct. 27th, 2026
ISBN: 978-0691293585
Publisher: Princeton Univ.

Schroeder takes an analytical look at the nature of interpersonal conflict.

In a series of personal anecdotes, anonymized stories, and extensive discussions, the author, a professor of philosophy at the University of Southern California, explores the ways in which interactions between people go from the trivial or merely informational to the personal. Central to his study is the concept of signal and noise: The signal is something directly attributable to a person, while the noise is nonpertinent background information that shouldn’t play any part in the interpretation of an interaction. “Our ability to apply the signal/noise distinction in interpreting one another,” the author contends, “allows us to cooperate and live together in diverse and complex ways of which we would otherwise not be capable.” Schroeder describes familiar scenarios in which people might readily misunderstand each other and then subjects these scenarios to detailed philosophical analysis. Focusing on the misapplication of signals, the author seeks to determine the extent of what he calls “error” in the process, which can lead to discord. Schroeder outlines ways of “latch[ing] on” to the philosophical concept of attributability to avoid the sometimes unrecognized discord that so often crops up in interactions. (“The difference between recognized and unrecognized discord,” he writes, “is just the difference between whether we recognize that someone else has a false belief about how to apply the signal/noise distinction.”) The author justifiably relies on his own rhetorical abilities throughout the work, effectively using stories to illustrate his concepts. Schroeder discusses growing a jasmine plant along his new home’s trellis, for instance, and then analyzes two hypothetical reactions from his wife: pleasure at how it looks and impatience at how long it took; examples like this really help to distinguish signal from noise. The text can read as being overly academic at times, but it offers much intriguing food for thought.

A clear, anecdote-driven consideration of how we communicate—and miscommunicate.