GUILTY CREATURES

The British American psychoanalyst and true crime author returns with an excavation of the luridness and venality underneath a smiling, all-American façade.

Brottman, author of An Unexplained Death, Thirteen Girls, and The Maximum Security Book Club, narrates the tangled story of two couples: Mike and Denise Williams and Brian and Kathy Winchester. They had been a tightknit group ever since high school, partying together on Saturday nights before going to church on Sunday mornings—until 2000, when Mike disappeared while duck hunting. Just a few years later, Brian divorced Kathy and married Denise. From there, the rumor mill in their community went into overtime. Had they been a couple before the divorce? Were they involved in Mike’s death? Brottman digs deeply into the investigation, which gripped the community and divided loyalties. With the help of a Tallahassee Democrat reporter and pressure from Mike’s mother, the case gathered momentum, and the public watched the murder trials live on YouTube. “It’s commonplace murders, not grotesque or bizarre ones, that hit the public nerve,” writes the author. “The Winchester-Williams case exemplified a kind of thrilling hubris: adulterous Baptist lovers beat a murder rap, collect on the insurance, but can’t escape each other. People love a tale of outrage and scandal; they love to witness the unmaking of those who haven’t practiced what they preach.” Through meticulous research, Brottman reconstructs the backgrounds of the principal players and provides context on the role of Christianity in their lives. Even though we know the ending, the author mostly holds readers’ attention; as the conclusion nears, she ratchets up the tension, unspooling the untimely end of Mike’s life and the desperate lengths to which his friend and wife went to cover it up.

An atmospheric tale that unwraps the wholesome, God-fearing exterior of two lovers to show the rot underneath.