In Verheyden’s thriller, when a free-spirited woman settles in a small Canadian town, horrifying secrets soon emerge.
On the outside, Pleasant Hill in Summerfield looks picture-perfect—but behind the charming veneer lurks a nightmare. Under the oppressive scrutiny of Holly and Homer Kent, the despicable founders of the local homeowner’s association (HOA), the residents of Pleasant Hill are anxious and suspicious. And that’s just how the Kents like it: For 30 years, the Kents have enforced the meticulous upkeep of lawns and houses and rigid rules about pets, noise, decorations, and vehicles. Their tactics of intimidation—including spying, inspections, and fines—usually keep the residents in check. But when Clementine Harrison, a 52-year-old photographer recovering from a breakup with her girlfriend, moves to town with her dog, George, and converted bus “Matilda,” the Kents may have finally met their match. The gregarious Clementine quickly finds her tribe, including no-nonsense senior Marjorie Burns and Valerie Park, who is relentlessly hounded by the HOA over her rewilded yard and whose late husband (who was of Korean descent) was the target of the Kents’ racism. Together, they vow to take down the Kents and unearth shocking truths. While the author introduces a huge cast to follow, the characters are well-crafted and sharply distinguished by their unique struggles. Though the plot relies on a few improbable coincidences, and the over-emphasized “you’ve got this” attitude among the women grows tiresome, Verheyden showcases her talent as a storyteller by skillfully dropping in clues that keep readers guessing, with prose that is punchy and sometimes darkly humorous. (“Didn’t they see that all of them would benefit if they’d just go along with what she wanted?” Holly thinks. “Why would anyone settle for staying ordinary if they could become extraordinary?”) Lighter moments are sharply contrasted with a compelling critique of power dynamics and timely explorations of addiction, sexual assault, and prejudice, resulting in a tale that oscillates between uplifting and sobering.
A promising debut packed with malevolent neighbors, juicy scandals, and cozy friendships.