Delving into destruction—“not the natural kind, but the unnatural kind.”
This “first history of the deliberate destruction of property” is the story of unquantifiable human-caused losses. A professor at the University of Toronto, Mount calculates the massive scale of elite acts targeting “treasured landmarks or art” (including books), far outdoing the idle barbarian treading on park grass. “Vandal” is conveniently applied to people deemed undesirable, though; like “Viking,” the eponymous “Vandal” was more a job-description than an ethnicity. In Part I, Mount looks at centuries of Western despoliation, including inter-Christian iconoclasm, Nazi looting, and Allied carpet-bombing, firebombing, and atomic bombing. Ranging globally, he identifies cultural replacement and colonial-clerical-commercial goals in Africa (Egyptian development by demolition), South America (the “Extirpation of Idolatry”), and Asia—including plunder in Tibet and the Cultural Revolution’s intra-Chinese devastation. He ends with the current war in Gaza. It’s quite a catalog. The powerful Egyptian ruler Hatshepsut gets notice as the earliest victim of, and inspiration for, the “template of vandalism”: The state needed to validate its succession narrative. Often, Mount notes, it’s the rhetoric accompanying destruction that matters—though, for the Reformation, destruction was the point. Distinguishing “affirmative vandalism,” “vindictive vandalism,” redevelopment clearances, and environmental depredation, Mount insists that state-authorized demolition is speciously rational and far more destructive than teenage hijinks or thuggery. He examines the motives of smash-and-burn, whether institutional or individual, by rulers or by rabble—most often, the former. Part II weighs what social sciences today can say about “the human impulse for destruction”: How do we understand, and respond to, prejudicial vandalism? An especially thought-provoking final section considers destruction’s political, socio-cultural, ideological, and artistic utility as well as its Janus-union with creation, suggesting a “theory of civilization.” Concise and conversational, Mount’s snappy style aptly serves his riveting subject. Neat turns of phrase in addition to incisive, sometimes irreverent, and memorable formulations, like “Iconoclasm is vandalism that matters,” give zest to the narrative.
An erudite, elegant, and intellectually engaging foray into human destructiveness.