THE HAPPINESS THIEF

In Bokat’s thriller, a troubled woman becomes entangled in a mystery during an island trip.

Natalie Greene, a 41-year-old food photographer, brings a lot of emotional baggage with her to the Cayman Islands, where her “powerhouse” stepsister, Isabel, a famous self-help guru, is the featured speaker at an upcoming Happiness Conference. Natalie’s stepfather recently died, and she’s haunted by a car crash nearly three decades ago that killed her mother. In addition, her husband has left her for another woman. The physical damage from the accident has healed except for the effects of a brain injury that erased much of her memory of the tragic incident. In the Caymans, she’s involved in another car accident at night; a strange man at the scene tells her and her stepsister that their vehicle hit a dog that then ran away. The next day, though, Natalie finds that her bumper, which had been spotted with blood, is now mysteriously clean. The mystery deepens when, upon her return to her home in Boston, she receives an anonymous email that reads, “You were lied to about that night. Have you asked your sister about the blood on the car? The guy who was there knows.” She soon meets Jeremy Sonnenberg, an investigative reporter writing a book about the happiness movement, and he helps her unravel a decades-old mystery. Bokat is an evocative wordsmith—as when she describes “sadness coating [Natalie] like oil”—and she has crafted a sympathetic heroine as her main character. Over the course of the novel, the author presents a psychologically nuanced portrait of a woman whose family regards her as “the sensitive one”; for example, when sparks fly between Natalie and Jeremy, she immediately wonders “if he was just another man who would disappoint her.” The book also reveals Natalie’s struggle not to be defined by her childhood trauma. Readers follow the protagonist as she works to untangle “a constrictor knot of lies” and wonders if she can have faith in people she’s always trusted.

A compulsively readable mystery and character study.