I, WITNESS by Norah McClintock

I, WITNESS

by , illustrated by
Age Range: 13 - 18

KIRKUS REVIEW

If it means putting yourself in danger, do you have to come forward as a witness?

Teenager David Boone and his friend Robbie witness a brutal murder. Boone talks Robbie out of going to the cops, and a few days later, Robbie’s killed in a drive-by. Boone and their friend Andre witness Robbie’s killing, but neither is willing to talk to the cops. When Boone is wounded and Andre killed at Robbie’s funeral, Boone is well and truly scared. Boone’s classmates call him coward; his dad sends him to a therapist. Detective Rylander practically begs him for help, but it takes another, unrelated murder to prompt Boone to come forward as a witness. Award-winning, Canadian writer of teen thrillers McClintock tries her hand at the graphic format with mixed results. Boone’s reasons for not coming forward are complex and interesting, but most of the supporting cast members are one-dimensional. The mystery Boone solves surrounding the unrelated murder will engage more than Boone’s repeated resistance to being a witness. Deas’ scratchy, mostly black-and-white panels look more like sketchbook filler than finished work; the characters are often hard to identify, and their emotions, not to mention ages, are difficult to gauge. However, the use of red as an accent in moments of violence is effective.

Bodies pile up around Boone like he's some teenage Jessica Fletcher, straining credulity but not sparking much interest. (Graphic thriller. 13 & up)

Pub Date: Oct. 1st, 2012
ISBN: 978-1-55469-789-2
Page count: 144pp
Publisher: Orca
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Oct. 1st, 2012




MORE BY NORAH MCCLINTOCK

ChildrenHIT AND RUN by Norah McClintock
by Norah McClintock
ChildrenIN TOO DEEP by Norah McClintock
by Norah McClintock
ChildrenCLOSE TO THE HEEL by Norah McClintock
by Norah McClintock

MORE BY MIKE DEAS

ChildrenPOWER PLAY by Liam O’Donnell
by Liam O’Donnell
ChildrenRAMP RATS by Liam O’Donnell
by Liam O’Donnell

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenYUMMY by G. Neri
by G. Neri
ChildrenAMERICUS by M.K. Reed
by M.K. Reed
ChildrenJANES IN LOVE by Cecil Castellucci
by Cecil Castellucci