SEASON FOR WAR by P. F. Kluge

SEASON FOR WAR

By
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

In 1929 elderly reporter Edwin Morrison, working from interviews, old journals, and his own memories, pieces together the 1884-1900 career of Capt. Henry Lawson--whose quest for military-hero status involves such issues as jingoistic/distorted journalism, manifest destiny, racism, and bureaucracy. Edwin meets Civil War hero Lawson back in 1884 through Mrs. Lawson: Edwin's ex-sweetheart Lucy, who has married career-soldier Henry with a ruthless determination that he--with Edwin's newspaper help--will become famous and powerful. And when Lawson's 25th Cavalry (virtually all-Negro) chases Apache ""renegades"" into a series of hapless ambushes and ugly skirmishes, Edwin does indeed turn an ignominious campaign into a media triumph. (""By the time I finished, I compared Lawson's descent into that thermal valley with Orpheus' journey into Hades."") During the next dozen years, however, with no war to wage, Lawson--a stolid sort not cut out for the politics of peace-time army careerism--fades from public view. while wife Lucy writhes with frustrated ambition. Then, at last: the Spanish-American conflict arrives--bringing Lawson to the Philippines, for a second chance to lock in his bid for soldier-celebrity; here again, out of love for Lucy and affection for Lawson, Edwin compromises his principles--ignoring the heroism of black Lieutenant Eccles and turning a virtual massacre on inept Filipino soldiers into a strategic feat for Lawson (who's out of his depth militarily). Finally, however, Lawson's desperate clutch at old-fashioned heroics--a vengeance-mission against Filipino guerrillas--leads to the decimation of his own troops. . . and his own death at the hands of traitor Lieutenant Eccles, who has formed a Third-World-ish alliance with the Filipinos. In outline, then, Kluge's is a basically familiar, somewhat heavyhanded morality-play from the annals of US ""imperialism""--its themes occasionally spelled out baldly. (A wise old journalist tells Edwin: ""You know what went wrong with this country?. . . We ran out of three things. We ran out of land. We ran out of Indians. And we ran out of ideas."") As a study of Edwin's journalistic immorality, it's thin and unconvincing. Throughout, however, Kluge (Eddie and the Cruisers) textures the didactic framework with fine character-shadings: Lawson, in many ways an admirable officer, is more victim than villain; Eccles is not so nobly motivated. And, with curious, balanced period-details (especially in the Philippines section), this is--notwithstanding the often-shrill message--strong, intriguing reading for a military-history audience.

Pub Date: Oct. 1st, 1984
Publisher: Freundlich--dist. by Scribners