CONSIDER THE EVIDENCE: Stories of Mystery and Suspense by Phyllis R. -- Ed. Fenner

CONSIDER THE EVIDENCE: Stories of Mystery and Suspense

By
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Maybe we're just stupefied by the babel of accents, but this collection of quirky crimes and trick solutions seems below the usual Fenner standard. The drawling protagonists include a ""gator bawling"" escaped convict in the Louisiana bayous, a not too bright cowboy outsmarted by a dog, and that lean old Sheriff Matt McQuestion (""Any sucker can make an arrest. The difficult thing is to know when not to""). Even Gallico's ""Roman Kid,"" in which a rube sportswriter has the final say in authenticating an ancient bronze statue, Kemelmen's tour de force of inference ""The Nine Mile Walk"" and McKinlay Kantor's ""The Grave Grass Quivers"" rely on outworn pulp stratagems. Taken one at a time these are bearable, read at one sitting they make one wonder whether dredging through back files of the Saturday Evening Post and Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine wouldn't make anyone a little punchy eventually.

Pub Date: Aug. 22nd, 1973
Publisher: Morrow