SILENT SHIP, SILENT SEA by Robb White
Kirkus Star

SILENT SHIP, SILENT SEA

By
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

War begins as calculated risk and becomes the commitment of two men to a battered hulk in Robb White's latest documentary-drama. It's 1942 and the destroyer Caron is off the Solomons. Aboard against his will is Kelsey Devereux, seaman second class who was slated to go to OCS; mama had already ordered his uniforms and he is forced to display them on deck, whereupon he is dubbed ""Admiral."" And then an enemy plane crashes against the superstructure; Kelsey calls ""Abandon ship"" and does; when he is fished out, all hands consider him a deserter. For a long time he has the worst of everything, with special attention from a sadistic bully, Ruddy, and his gang. Simultaneously the ship is completely disabled off Guadal-canal by a Japanese torpedo and the Captain does the unprecedented: he offers each man the choice of leaving the ship or remaining on board for the long, slow drift--fifty days is the estimate--to Australia. Most, including Kelsey, stay. Now it's salt water showers and k-rations and tedium. In small and large ways, Kelsey emerges as a man; when he knocks out the invincible Ruddy in desperate self-defense, he is a man to look up to. And in small and large ways, the Captain and Kelsey draw closer, a relationship that is confirmed when the two find themselves on board alone after the ship passes an Australian island, and sealed with the presentation of lieutenant's bars--the Captain's own--to Kelsey. This last is almost maudlin, and the denouement is almost melodrama, but the hard core of carefully established character prevails: being who they are, this is how they might be. With a quick hook and a steady pull, divided between concern for the ship and concern for the men, this should go as well as its predecessors.

Pub Date: Aug. 18th, 1967
Publisher: Doubleday