Kirkus Reviews QR Code
WEIRD ERA by Ryan Schreiber Kirkus Star

WEIRD ERA

How Pitchfork Changed Music Forever: A Memoir

by Ryan Schreiber

Pub Date: Dec. 1st, 2026
ISBN: 9780374605506
Publisher: MCD/Farrar, Straus and Giroux

The rise of an online music tastemaker.

“I had never even seen a shooting star before” begins an infamous Pitchfork review of Radiohead’s Kid A. The review, one of the few albums that garnered a perfect 10.0 score on the site, would come to represent the quintessential Pitchfork review—stylistic, unpredictable, and perfectly calibrated to go viral on the still-new internet of the early 2000s. This memoir, which traces Schreiber’s life from his childhood in the 1980s and ’90s through his departure from Pitchfork in 2019, offers readers a glimpse behind the scenes of this early-aughts internet staple. Schreiber started Pitchfork in 1996 in his parents’ Minnesota home and gained attention for his willingness to harshly criticize bands that larger publications wouldn’t. The band Jet, for example, received a 3.7 and a 0.0 for their two albums in the early 2000s, one of which simply linked to a vulgar video of a monkey. Schreiber tackles these and other reviews with humor and grace, such as his own regrettably slang-filled review of a John Coltrane live album (“some style, man. Some richness, daddy,” it reads) and the postmodern scrawls of Brent DiCrescenzo, who got the site in legal trouble for a Beastie Boys review in which he smeared the band’s PR firm. Schreiber started Pitchfork with little writing experience, but, 30 years later, he has gained an incisive reviewing style that he aptly turns on his own life. Early stories of his confusing, burgeoning sexuality and issues with bullying are especially affecting, and indie music fans will enjoy hearing about his evolving taste in music. Later chapters deal with the author’s mixed feelings about Pitchfork’s acquisition by Condé Nast, offering insight into the changing landscape of media and music. This memoir delivers as an ode to the early internet and a love letter to criticism.

A must for 21st-century music snobs.