CULTURE CRASH by Scott Timberg


The Killing of the Creative Class
Email this review


A journalist investigates the state of the arts.

Anger infuses ArtsJournal editor Timberg’s (co-author, Misread City: New Literary Los Angeles, 2003) report on threats to the “creative class,” which he defines, broadly, as “anyone who helps create or disseminate culture,” including artists, musicians, librarians and architects, as well as “their often-mocked supporting casts—record store clerks, roadies, critics, publicists, and supposedly exploitative record label folk…deejays, bookstore clerks, theater and set designers, people who edit books in publishing houses, and so on.” The author, who lost his job as a reporter at the Los Angeles Times as a result of downsizing, has found that many others like him—creative types wanting only to support themselves and their families— have been hurt since the recession began in 2008. Some have been forced into the “gig economy,” fighting “to keep a home, a livelihood, or medical coverage” while taking low-paying freelance jobs. Free agency, rather than allowing people “to live flexible and self-determining lives full of meaning,” instead makes their lives precarious. Among forces undermining the creative class are the culture of celebrity, corporations’ emphasis on the monetary return of arts and entertainment, and growing income inequality. In academia, the author contends that the professoriate “is de-professionalized the same way journalism has been,” with adjuncts replacing tenured professors and a few superstars hired to teach thousands of students in profitable online courses. In response to his dismal findings, Timberg offers a few ardent but vague suggestions: “stirring passion for culture in schoolkids and college students”; inspiring academics to address readers outside of their narrow fields; expanding “midlist” offerings by book publishers and movie companies; and reviving vigorous public support for culture.

Timberg’s bibliographic essay cites many authors echoing his arguments; a more focused analysis and concrete solutions would have strengthened this book.

Pub Date: Jan. 13th, 2015
ISBN: 978-0300195880
Page count: 320pp
Publisher: Yale Univ.
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 1st, 2014


NonfictionFREE RIDE by Robert Levine
by Robert Levine
NonfictionTHE PRICE OF EVERYTHING by Eduardo Porter
by Eduardo Porter
NonfictionHOW MUSIC GOT FREE by Stephen Witt
by Stephen Witt