A sequel to the darkly adorable How To Kill a Guy in Ten Dates (2026).
Thompson’s first novel was the story of Jamie Prescott, a slasher-flick aficionado who survives a deadly night of speed dating. One of the pleasures of that book was Jamie’s BFF, Laurie Hamilton. Rather than being a sidekick useful for moving the plot forward as needed, Laurie emerged as a fully developed character, and Thompson treated the friendship between these two with as much care as she treated the romance between the male and female main characters. Here, Laurie gets a star turn, and the results are disappointing. A filmmaker languishing at a content farm, Laurie can’t turn down the opportunity to work on a juicy documentary even if it means pretending to be in love with Connor Kincaid. Both her college rival and secret crush, Connor is someone Laurie has spent the last decade trying not to think about. When she joins him for a couples retreat, she has to fight off that old attraction while trying to figure out if Kindred Souls is just a New Age sex thing or a doomsday cult. Thompson’s romance-horror mashup was clever and beautifully executed. She delivered the mandatory happily-ever-after while also providing serious chills and delightful twists. Tossing main characters into a volatile situation is a classic romance move, but nothing about Kindred Souls feels fresh—in large part because it’s pretty clearly inspired by the Twin Flames Universe, a high-control grift that has been thoroughly explored in documentaries, podcasts, and articles. The enemies-to-lovers trope is at least as old as Shakespeare, but the sparring between Laurie and Connor gets old pretty quick. The problem is that Laurie is so determined to maintain her loathing for Connor that she fails to notice he consistently treats her with respect and kindness (she does notice that he’s still hot, at least). Her treatment of Connor eventually feels mean and immature rather than playful.
After a terrific debut, a sophomore slump.