BENEFIT

A struggling American academic reluctantly reunites with members of her Oxford graduate-fellowship cohort.

Laura Graham’s life is not going well in the fall of 2011: She wasn’t rehired for her adjunct teaching position at a women’s college near Boston, hasn’t found a permanent tenure-track position, and is stalled on an essay she’s writing about Henry James. Strapped for money, she moves back home with her mother and takes a contract job writing the history of the Weatherfield Foundation, which sponsored the Oxford fellowship for “students of promise and ambition” she'd won 10 years earlier. Working on this essay, which will be used as part of a celebration of the foundation, takes Laura on two different journeys: First, she embarks on a historical excavation of the sugar business that created the fortune behind the prestigious fellowships, including its involvement in slavery, war, and exploitation; and second, she takes a number of trips around New England to meet up with the former members of her fellowship cohort, all much more successful than her, if also intolerably shallow. Author Phillips was a Rhodes scholar; her depictions of Laura’s research, social life, and failed job search highlight the toxicity and ethical gaps that underlie much of modern academia and philanthropy. The novel plays with structure and style, which slows the momentum of the narrative considerably at first. The second half of the novel, in which Laura begins to confront the expectations and falsity of the foundation’s work and her friends, is more absorbing in its forcefulness.

An uneven debut novel with striking social commentary.