Starting middle school without her best friend compels an Indian American girl to navigate changing friendships and grow in her self-confidence in 1991 Winterville, Michigan.
After her best friend moves away, Priya finds herself anxiously facing sixth grade alone. She reconnects with old friends—Japanese American Akiko and Italian American Danny—while also forging a friendship with white-presenting new girl Jessie. As the year unfolds, Priya feels pressured by Jessie to reinvent herself in order to fit in with the unkind popular girls. Jessie pushes Priya to abandon Indian traditions and to stay on the sidelines while Danny and Akiko enjoy activities she’d love to take part in, like joining the history team, playing tag, and engaging in activism. But through this struggle, Priya finds her voice; ultimately, she challenges the American melting pot ideal, instead embracing a “potluck” model, where people contribute to a richer whole by retaining their different cultural identities. As Priya’s confidence grows, her friendship with Jessie fades, and she becomes truer to her friends, her family, her culture, and, most importantly, herself. Although the writing in Kelkar’s semiautobiographical story feels stiff and occasionally message-driven, the celebration of self-acceptance and recognition of overlooked perspectives in history make this a worthwhile read. The lively illustrations, as well as the epistolary interludes, add warmth and humor, balancing the sometimes wooden dialogue and too-tidy ending.
A sincere story that will please readers seeking stories about identity, inclusion, and under-represented history.
(author’s note) (Graphic fiction. 8-12)