THE FIND OF A LIFE-TIME: Sir Arthur Evans and the Discovery of Knossos by Sylvia L. Horwitz

THE FIND OF A LIFE-TIME: Sir Arthur Evans and the Discovery of Knossos

By
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Horwitz is the author of two solid juvenile biographies, and this study of dapper, driven archaeologist Evans (1851-1941) has a for-young-adults aroma about it--a tendency toward trite phrasings and chipper smoothings-over of complexities. Still, there's a stab at psychological insight at the outset: the death of young Arthur's mother left him with the need ""to avoid deep relationships that might incur future losses""; competition with father John, a notable amateur pre-historian, supplied a push to short, myopic, stubborn Arthur. And thereafter Horwitz covers everything in Evans' 90 years with conscientious evenness: youthful travels in the Balkans and lifelong support for nationalistic insurgents there (which once led to six weeks in Austrian prison); a happy, foreshortened marriage to ill, selfless Margaret (""would she ever take precedence over his self-imposed goals?""); aggressive curatorship of Oxford's Ashmolean Museum. But the raison d'être here, of course, is Knossos--the dig on Crete inspired by Evans' visit with Heinrich Schliemann, when he noticed the Aegean octopus design on excavated Greek-mainland objects and intuited a pre-Mycenaean civilization in the Aegean. Unlike the Carter/Tutankhamen ordeal, however, there's minimal drama leading up to Evans' 1900 discovery; made possible by family money, his first Cretan site produced major results in less than a week: the throne-room of legendary King Minos, to be followed (over two decades) by a Royal Villa, Temple Repositories, flush toilets, and further evidence of an advanced culture that (according to Evans) was merely imitated by the Greeks. Horwitz conveys just a hint of the fascination in these labyrinthine unearthings and in the exacting process of simultaneous excavation-and-reconstruction. So the only real flickers of drama here come from the controversies over Evans' methods and interpretations: his apparent hoarding of tablets of script so that he could be the first to decipher them; his perhaps over-imaginative restoration, of frescoes especially; opposing theories about chronology, about the nature of the Knossos temple (most recently Hans Wunderlich's The Secret of Crete argues that it was all a mortuary). Other than a brief summary of the 1961 Cretological Congress, however, Horwitz generally skirts over the debates, refraining from judgments; instead she follows Sir Arthur through his vigorous last years and ends up with some sentimental tourist-brochure prose (his ""buoyant step still seems to accompany the visitor idling his way along the sinuous paths. . .""). Despite the careful, balanced approach, then--an only half-compelling life story, with a presentation of the dig itself that's too superficial for savvy Knossos followers, too unfocused to grab newcomers.

Pub Date: Jan. 1st, 1980
Publisher: Viking