Worshipping the twin gods of creativity and innovation may have doomed the American democratic experiment.
Cultural and political analyst Frank (What’s the Matter With Kansas?, 2004, etc.) excoriates the disastrous results of the American love affair with “innovation.” In the postwar United States, creativity (the inventions of the human mind) became identified with innovation (the relentless push for novelty). This conflation, he argues, buttressed political elites but did not improve the nation’s economy, benefiting the wealthy while taking jobs away from the poor. The trouble began with the dubious teachings of super-salesman Alex F. Osborn of the New York advertising agency Batten, Barton, Durstine & Osborn, who in Applied Imagination (1953) declared that creativity was universal. Over the next few decades, it became anything but that. With music and the liberal arts in “free-fall” today and manufacturing largely moved offshore, the U.S. has morphed into, Frank writes, “a postindustrial plutocracy in which Silicon Valley billionaires stride the earth like lords of creation, starting bespoke political movements and launching stuff into space.” It’s hard to finger specific culprits, but he devotes probing chapters to presidents and other politicians, on the right as well as the left, who, in the name of innovation, elevated software-makers, deregulated banks, cut taxes for the rich, built lifestyle “playgrounds” for yuppies in derelict cities, and reconfigured universities as incubators of new businesses (thus, sending tuition spiraling “upward into the stratosphere”). While some perpetrators of the creativity con might claim noble intentions, its willing beneficiaries can’t. The author mentions Elizabeth Holmes, whose sham blood-testing company Theranos coasted to short-lived success on the fraudulent wings of innovation-speak. A pithy and entertaining writer, Frank has a special talent for the trenchant quip: “The amount of high‑IQ brilliance that has gone into preventing farmers from repairing their own machinery would probably be enough to power several Manhattan Projects.” Long on condemnation and, given the scale of the problem, short on advice, this alarming book offers no prescriptions for the future but teaches readers to be wary whenever someone wields the C-word.
A spirited indictment of the American obsession with innovation.