THIS STORY MIGHT SAVE YOUR LIFE

A Los Angeles–based podcaster is AWOL in Crum’s debut, a thriller-romance mashup.

Joy Moore, one half of the chart-topping “comedy survival podcast” This Story Might Save Your Life, is acting strange. She privately tells her co-podcaster and best friend, Benny Abbott, that she wants to take a break from podcasting and will explain why later. The next day, when Benny arrives to record at the home Joy shares with her husband, Xander, who handles podcast business, the couple isn’t there and the house appears vandalized. Benny phones Joy and Xander, but they don’t pick up. He summons the cops and reminds them that Joy is being stalked by someone who “claims to be our biggest fan” and demonstrates this by secretly snapping her picture and posting the images on social media. When it comes to Joy’s stalker, the police have been useless—“They say it doesn’t fit the definition of harassment or something,” Benny grouses—so what’s a podcaster to do but ask his listeners for help? Crum has a smart solution to the problem of how to maintain the mystery of Joy’s whereabouts without sacrificing the character’s viewpoint: The novel’s first half largely alternates between Benny’s present-day narration and Joy-authored chapters pulled from the memoir she and Benny are cowriting. This way, the novel’s readers hear from both parties on the matter consuming Joy’s and Benny’s listeners: As Joy puts it, “Everyone, literally everyone, asks if we were ever romantically involved.” The novel’s did-they-or-didn’t-they/will-they-or-won’t-they tease goes down like a fizzy drink until the story takes a surprising turn at the midpoint. Here the plot sheds much of its mystery and a bit of its allure, although by book’s end, Crum has reconstituted that initial sizzle.

This mystery’s foremost puzzle? The human heart.