Kirkus Reviews QR Code
INQUISITION by Toby Green Kirkus Star

INQUISITION

The Reign of Fear

by Toby Green

Pub Date: March 17th, 2009
ISBN: 978-0-312-53724-1
Publisher: Dunne/St. Martin's

Images and insights distilled from a record of terrors inflicted over nearly four centuries.

Green (Thomas More’s Magician, 2005, etc.) unflinchingly tackles one of civilization’s most notorious ventures into authoritarian religious intolerance and racism: the Spanish Inquisition, endowed by papal bull in 1478 and ended by decree only in 1834. Much of the documentation here is from the Iberian Peninsula, which became obsessed with heresy after ending seven centuries of tolerant Islamic rule in the 15th century. Spain and Portugal were under one reign for 90 years of the relevant period, and even when governed separately favored the same repressive methodology: paranoia fostered by those in power, evidence of heresy or deviance from Catholic doctrine taken from secret witnesses and torture employed to extract confessions. It all culminated in a feverish public auto da fé (trial of faith), during which those deemed the worst offenders were burned alive, lesser ones garroted first or given sentences of prison or servitude. Green is incisive in spotting both extremes and subtle variations as this traveling show moved from city to town over the centuries. Former Jews who had converted under duress (conversos) were harassed in the 15th century, their Islamic counterparts (moriscos) a hundred years later, and both groups were eventually expelled from Spain at the expense of diversity. (Portugal assimilated its Moorish population.) The author points out that the Church in Rome regularly decried these extreme actions, but never actively opposed monarchies that saw fear as a primary means of imposing civil order. Ultimately, the Inquisition was a tool more political than religious, the author concludes. Between the lines lies a haunting message supported by massive evidence: Suspects under torture will confess to anything and falsely inform on others to end their suffering, even if this testimony assures their own deaths.

A persuasive proposal that two rich empires took a dark detour from Europe’s Enlightenment and never completely recovered.