These rules come with a powerful subtext that seems to say that theft is wrong, but manipulation may be acceptable.



From the Cody series , Vol. 3

Big brother Wyatt pays more attention to his new bike than to Cody, who helped assemble it, but when it’s stolen, her jealousy turns to empathy—she’s just lost something precious herself.

Excited about her first sleepover, at Pearl’s, Cody—a little nervous—brings her beloved toy, Gremlin, for comfort. Smitten with Gremlin, Pearl elicits a trade, insisting Cody choose among Pearl’s valuable collection of plush endangered animals. Cody accedes reluctantly. Her misery grows as her attempts to reverse the trade are rebuffed. Finally, she steals Gremlin back, angering Pearl when she finds out. The titular rules concern honesty and tact. When does borrowing become stealing? What constitutes permission? Here, theme and plot are at odds. Pearl, depicted as Asian in the lighthearted illustrations (Cody is white), is endowed with “model minority” attributes: good student, talented musician, origami whiz, pretty, well-liked. She follows rules. “If Pearl were an animal, she’d be a star puppy in obedience school,” Cody reflects. Stereotyping aside, Pearl’s manipulations, on her own turf and later, counter that portrait. Cody’s held at fault for secretly stealing Gremlin back, Pearl merely for her indignant response, while her culpability in forcing the trade goes unmentioned.

These rules come with a powerful subtext that seems to say that theft is wrong, but manipulation may be acceptable. (Fiction. 7-10)

Pub Date: April 11, 2017

ISBN: 978-0-7636-7920-0

Page Count: 176

Publisher: Candlewick

Review Posted Online: Dec. 26, 2016

Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 15, 2017

Did you like this book?

No Comments Yet

Sweetly low-key and totally accessible.

Our Verdict

  • Our Verdict
  • GET IT

  • Kirkus Reviews'
    Best Books Of 2013

  • New York Times Bestseller

  • Newbery Honor Book


Billy Miller’s second-grade year is quietly spectacular in a wonderfully ordinary way.

Billy’s year begins with his worry over the lump on his head, a souvenir of a dramatic summer fall onto concrete: Will he be up to the challenges his new teacher promises in her letter to students? Quickly overshadowing that worry, however, is a diplomatic crisis over whether he has somehow offended Ms. Silver on the first day of school. Four sections—Teacher, Father, Sister and Mother—offer different and essential focal points for Billy’s life, allowing both him and readers to explore several varieties of creative endeavor, small adventures, and, especially, both challenges and successful problem-solving. The wonderfully self-possessed Sal, his 3-year-old sister, is to Billy much as Ramona is to Beezus, but without the same level of tension. Her pillowcase full of the plush yellow whales she calls the Drop Sisters (Raindrop, Gumdrop, etc.) is a memorable prop. Henkes offers what he so often does in these longer works for children: a sense that experiences don’t have to be extraordinary to be important and dramatic. Billy’s slightly dreamy interior life isn’t filled with either angst or boisterous silliness—rather, the moments that appear in these stories are clarifying bits of the universal larger puzzle of growing up, changing and understanding the world. Small, precise black-and-white drawings punctuate and decorate the pages.

Sweetly low-key and totally accessible. (Fiction. 7-10)

Pub Date: Sept. 17, 2013

ISBN: 978-0-06-226812-9

Page Count: 240

Publisher: Greenwillow Books

Review Posted Online: April 24, 2013

Kirkus Reviews Issue: July 15, 2013

Did you like this book?

No Comments Yet

Young readers will recognize Suds as one of their own and will gladly follow him to fourth grade. Sweet and funny.


Suds Morton is not yet a “Fourth Grade Rat.” In this prequel to Spinelli's 1991 standby, he is a year younger and, according to his school’s traditional chant, he aspires to the sobriquet of “Third Grade Angel.”

When his teacher announces her intention of rewarding angelic behavior with a halo, Suds decides he wants to be the first angel. Between his cool new friend Joey, his wise mom and a little conclusion-jumping, he comes up with a plan. But, of course, his results are just a little off-kilter. Suds, nicknamed for his preference for calming soaks in bubble baths when he gets “chipmunky,” needs all the help he can get to deal with the various disasters and tribulations that threaten to overwhelm him. Along with the angel chase there’s a pesky little sister, a fifth-grade bully and total rejection by the girl he adores. Spinelli doesn’t miss a beat in recreating the characters from the earlier work and never reveals any hint of Suds’ fourth-grade future. He lets readers into Suds’ 8-year-old mind without condescension. His problems and concerns are treated comically but with genuine kindness. Suds is innocent, gullible and trusting; he is also entirely good-hearted.

Young readers will recognize Suds as one of their own and will gladly follow him to fourth grade. Sweet and funny. (Fiction. 7-10)

Pub Date: Sept. 1, 2012

ISBN: 978-0-545-38772-9

Page Count: 160

Publisher: Levine/Scholastic

Review Posted Online: July 18, 2012

Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 1, 2012

Did you like this book?

No Comments Yet