Kirkus Reviews QR Code
THE ISLANDS by Dionne Irving

THE ISLANDS

by Dionne Irving

Pub Date: Nov. 1st, 2022
ISBN: 978-1646220663
Publisher: Catapult

An expansive collection of stories chronicling the Jamaican diaspora.

In this assured collection, Canadian writer Irving follows the threads of colonialism, exile, and immigration throughout the 20th and 21st centuries. “Canal” connects Jamaica, Panama, postwar Germany, and Canada through the figure of a girl forced to flee as a result of American intervention. In “The Gifts,” the book’s moving penultimate installment, a young woman named Peaches moves to “Foreign” (England) to find work and winds up serving as both maid and mistress in the same family. Irving’s writing is most effective when she homes in on a smaller domestic scene—for instance, the mismatched married couple in “The Cape” is divided by age and a sudden injury—but the international range and scope of her collection give it breadth and freshness. Despite the book's wide range of locales, Irving's writing of place always feels assured. Her prose is smooth and unfussy despite occasional clunky sentences (“When he gets home she will be broken. Not by him, but in spite of him”). Although the collection is enjoyable, Irving’s construction of narrative can sometimes feel predictable: In several stories, characters are first presented one way—racist hicks; an earnest but clueless White mother; a long-lost parent—only for Irving to introduce a shift in perspective that encourages the reader not to judge so hastily. But a careful reader (or a frequent reader of short story collections) will soon become familiar with this convention, and instead of leading to a feeling of real enlightenment, the stories will feel tired. Irving is at her best in odd, harsh moments: a gruesome fireworks injury in “The Cape”; an estranged father stealing a pig for his daughter in “Weaving.”

A first collection that hints at bigger things to come.