GRANFA' GRIG HAD A PIG and Other Rhymes Without Reason from Mother Goose by Wallace--Illus. Tripp

GRANFA' GRIG HAD A PIG and Other Rhymes Without Reason from Mother Goose

By
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Tripp's oversize package is chock full of rhymes, some of them new to us, but the thrown-together look doesn't invite browsing. Neither do the crowded double pages--each shared by several rhymes with separate illustrations--reward attention: most of the high-pitched pictures are surprisingly uninventive. And where one picture does get a full double-page it proves either too slight to survive the inflation or discordantly frenzied--as is the family of madmen dancing in hell, where a claw-footed Hitler in uniform and holster lines up with Cerberus and other stranger creatures. (Most of Tripp's characters are animals but there are other human caricatures--Teddy Roosevelt appears as the drummer boy of King Cole, a lion.) And as for the stabs at verbal wit, neither the doctor in ""An Apple a Day"" (a duck berated as a ""Quack"" and ""Hippocratic oaf"") nor the tub of ""Rub a Dub Dub"" (it's named ""Quiet Desperation"") will mean much to the nursery rhyme audience. Overall, aggressively tasteless.

Pub Date: Nov. 11th, 1976
Publisher: Little, Brown