Forewarned is Forearmed

A little linguistic advice

This tomato simply did not exist in medieval pre-Columbus Italy.

Since Kirkus Indie reviewers have critiqued thousands of memoirs, novels, mysteries, thrillers, etc., we thought we’d call on them occasionally to share insight and advice from the front lines of self-publishing. In this issue, several veteran reviewers note the recurring errors they spot on their sojourns through Indieland.

Ivan Kenneally, who also writes for the Los Angeles Review of Books and Open Letters Monthly, bemoans the rampant misuse of the semicolon, which is “apparently a great grammatical mystery,” he says. In a meta moment, he notes, “the em-dash is used too promiscuously—it’s a punctuational epidemic. And pronouns...don’t get me started on the practice of starting a paragraph with a pronoun without an antecedent referent.”

Fuzzy details plague reviewers. Hannah Sheldon-Dean, who reviews nonfiction, says, “Authors of books on self-help and spirituality in particular tend to offer vague advice that often just repeats things we’ve all heard before—‘have faith,’ for example.”

Sheldon-Dean says that, while reviewing, she looks for concrete details that explain how to implement the suggested self-help strategies or systems of belief. “For authors, a good test of this is to read over the advice you’re giving, and then ask yourself: What exactly would it look like for a person to follow this advice? If you can’t get a clear picture, then you’re not being specific enough.”

Stephanie Cerra has reviewed hundreds of Indie titles, and anachronisms drive her batty. “Nothing destroys the illusion of historicity like seeing tomatoes in medieval pre-Columbus Italy or a Regency hero with a first name like Brayden,” she says. “This applies to behavior also: a well-brought-up Victorian girl would not defy her society without a second thought. Anachronisms make a book appear sloppy, lazy, and underresearched.” —K.S.

Karen Schechner is the senior Indie editor at Kirkus Reviews.


D.J. Molles
He wrote to satisfy his own interests until readers started catching on
Sometimes success finds you when you stop trying to find success. Take D.J. Molles: he stopped writing altogether after a number of rejections, staying busy with his day job as a police officer. Then he started writing again but wrote for himself, with no thought of getting published. The result was The Remaining, the first book of what is ...
Fan Fiction: Writing for the Love of It
Creating new stories from established ones has become a true phenomenon
Fan fiction has become a true phenomenon. Websites such as and Archive of Our Own boast millions of self-published stories, written by fans and set in the fictional worlds of book series such as Harry Potter and Twilight and TV series such as Star Trek, Supernatural, Teen Wolf, and many others, with more added every day. As Anne ...
Adding to the Historical Record
Within Indie publishing, voices or stories that might otherwise be ignored get their opportunity to be heard. We often see titles that explore some corner of social-justice or civil rights issues, adding detail and diversity to the historic record. In Destiny’s Child: Memoirs of a Preacher’s Daughter, Taylor Gibbs gives a firsthand account of her family’s work with Eleanor Roosevelt ...