The World's Toughest Book Critics ℠
 
Cover art for A TALE DARK & GRIMM
Rate this book:
Loved it
Liked it
Meh...
Don't bother

A TALE DARK & GRIMM

Age Range: 10 - 13
Fairy tales for the horror set blend themselves into one intact thread that's satisfying enough to overcome an intrusive narrator. Read full review
Buy this book from
Buy this book from Amazon
Buy this book from Barnes and Noble
Buy this book from IndieBound
Save for later:
Add to my list
Similar books suggested by our critics:
Cover art for RECKLESS
by Cornelia Funke
Cover art for LUKA AND THE FIRE OF LIFE
by Salman Rushdie
Cover art for THE DRAGON'S TOOTH
by N.D. Wilson
 
Cover art for WHERE THE STREETS HAD A NAME
by Randa Abdel-Fattah
Cover art for A TIME OF MIRACLES
by Anne-Laure Bondoux
Cover art for MATCHED
by Ally Condie
Cover art for OLD BEAR AND HIS CUB
by Olivier Dunrea
Cover art for LOTS OF DOTS
by Craig Frazier
Cover art for THE SWEETNESS OF SALT
by Cecilia Galante
 
A TALE DARK & GRIMM (reviewed on October 15, 2010)
Fairy tales for the horror set blend themselves into one intact thread that’s satisfying enough to overcome an intrusive narrator. The storyteller’s voice (presented in bold type) opens by asserting that original Grimm tales are “awesome,” “violent and ... bloody,” while “all the versions of the stories you’ve heard [are]… mind-numbingly boring” due to sanitization. It’s an odd premise for a piece whose audience is surely aware of many fractured fairy tales that are dark and/or awesome. The narrator contributes unnecessary platitudes, but on the plus side, savvily warns when little kids should leave the room, effectively cautioning big kids that upcoming content is sad or gory—and it really is. Heads are lopped off, blood flows, men reach down girls’ throats and pull out their souls. Old Grimm tales and Gidwitz’s original additions weave together into one arc, with fiercely loyal siblings Hansel and Gretel at the heart. The narrator’s presence lessens; action and emotion deepen; funny gross-outs pop up amid serious violence; and everything builds to one painful and triumphant catharsis. (Fractured fairy tale. 10-13)

Pub Date: Nov. 1st, 2010
ISBN: 978-0-525-42334-8
Page count: 256pp
Publisher: Dutton
Review Posted Online: Sept. 24th, 2010
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Oct. 15th, 2010