The World's Toughest Book Critics ℠
 
Cover art for A MOTHER’S SONG
Rate this book:
Loved it
Liked it
Meh...
Don't bother

A MOTHER’S SONG

Age Range: 3 - 5
From spring through winter a mother celebrates her bond with her daughter in syrupy, limping doggerel. Read full review
Buy this book from
Buy this book from Amazon
Buy this book from Barnes and Noble
Buy this book from IndieBound
Save for later:
Add to my list
MORE BY JANET LAWLER
Cover art for IF KISSES WERE COLORS
by Janet Lawler
Cover art for TYRANNOCLAUS
by Janet Lawler
 
MORE BY KATHLEEN KEMLY
Cover art for A FISHING SURPRISE
by Rae A. McDonald
Cover art for GOLDEN DELICIOUS
by Anna Egan Smucker
 
A MOTHER’S SONG (reviewed on March 15, 2010)

From spring through winter a mother celebrates her bond with her daughter in syrupy, limping doggerel. “Listen with me / to the happiest birds / calling, ‘Good morning!’ / with chirp-chirping words.” The verse marches along in lockstep, forcing unnatural stresses to maintain scansion. While there is the occasional fresh image—“Feel summer showers / fall cool on our toes, / before running off / to wherever rain goes”—the text is only distinguished by its appeal to the maudlin. Kemly’s soft pastels largely reflect the text’s aesthetic, but she adds a small black-and-white dog to most double-page spreads, which provides continuity and a bit of fun. There’s no question this mother-daughter pair is enjoying each other’s company, but this is far from the only book with such a portrayal. (Picture book. 3-5)


Pub Date: April 1st, 2010
ISBN: 978-1-4027-6968-9
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Sterling
Review Posted Online: June 2nd, 2010
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 15th, 2010