"Bittersweet in the Bitterroot: Murder, meth and mystery in Montana. In a word: marvelous. Revolving around a young FBI agent on her first case, this seamless fusion of thriller and police procedural is tonally comparable to Thomas Harris' iconic The Silence of the Lambs."– Kirkus Reviews
In Orlo’s (The Christmas Cougar, 2015, etc.) thriller, a Montana cop hunts his partner’s assailant.
Lt. Thomas Catlin is all set for his San Diego vacation. After all, he and partner Sgt. Delores Delaney have just nabbed an elusive criminal, and because he still doesn’t know why girlfriend Suzanne Oberton isn’t speaking to him, Catlin could definitely use a break. His getaway is cut short when Suzanne calls to tell him someone gunned down Delaney at her apartment. The sergeant’s still alive but only barely, and Catlin’s determined to find her attacker. After he digs into Delaney’s cases, the lieutenant realizes that a hit was ordered, and his search widens to include both the shooter and his employer. This involves questioning a few seedy individuals. As he navigates this underworld, Catlin’s own ethics begin to crumble; he punches a man at the police station when his lawyer’s out of the room. Not surprisingly, it isn’t long before the bad guys target him, too. Orlo rarely misses an opportunity to inject action into his plotlines. The novel opens with Catlin and Delaney at the hotel room of a sure-to-be-armed suspect, and even scenes without baddies or guns are frantic, such as Catlin getting from California back to Missoula as quickly as possible. Though Catlin’s method of investigation entails too much machismo, this mystery is delightfully enigmatic. Technology plays a significant role; Catlin often relies on “gadget geek” Matthew. Unfortunately, tech-relevant descriptions are either off-kilter or superfluous: Catlin, in a return text, “poked into the reply space,” while Matthew later tells the cop how to play a DVD (“Just stick it in your disk drive, and it’ll start to play”).
An absorbing investigation energizes both the plot and the tough-guy lead.
Orlo’s debut crime novel offers complicated, compelling characters.
Mikey, Benny and Mary are three friends who were raised in the same trailer park in similarly broken families. Their parents were alcoholics, prostitutes or completely absent. During high school, in order to make enough money to survive, Mikey and Benny trafficked drugs for a local kingpin, Tony Richards. When it came time to graduate, Mikey and Benny joined the Marines, while Mary, only 16 at the time, was forced to marry Tony to escape her abusive home. As the novel begins, Benny and Mikey return to Missoula to kill Tony and escape with Mary; they have a plan to start a farm together in Canada. The two former Marines succeed in killing Tony, along with his primary associates, which puts Missoula Police Detective Thomas Catlin and his partner, Sgt. Delores Delaney, on their trail. Thomas Catlin leads a fairly solitary life, but the intricacies of his personality are revealed methodically, and rewardingly, throughout the story. Mary eventually manages to earn Catlin’s sympathy, and she offers him a book containing all of Tony’s criminal contacts in exchange for leniency in his pursuit. Unfortunately, nothing goes according to plan, as Tony’s book provokes attacks from unknown entities. The author describes Mikey, Benny and Mary in ways that are clearly meant to elicit empathy from the reader, and in many ways, it feels justified. The novel’s isolated Montana setting and the trailer-park backgrounds of the main characters give the novel a grim realism. Mikey’s, Benny’s and Mary’s dispassionate attitudes toward murder, however, may be too off-putting for readers to see them as sympathetic victims enacting justice. Readers may also find that the story offers relatively few dramatic twists, and its conclusion seems a bit rushed and inconsequential, despite the well-developed characters.
An often engaging, if uneven, mystery novel.
Revolving around a young FBI agent on her first case, this seamless fusion of thriller and police procedural is tonally comparable to Thomas Harris’ iconic The Silence of the Lambs.
Set largely in and around the breathtaking Bitterroot Mountains in Montana, the story begins with fledgling FBI agent Maria Hernandez investigating the murder of a girl whose corpse was found off a hiking trail in the mountains. The local sheriff’s main suspect is the man who found the body, Joseph Deerling, the editor of a local weekly news journal. Deerling has had numerous run-ins with the law, but Hernandez quickly realizes that Deerling is not the murderer. In fact, when it is reported that another teenage girl has gone missing in the same area, Deerling and Hernandez join forces to find the killer’s lair, which Deerling believes may be located in a virtually inaccessible area in the mountains. The collaboration pays off, and after a brief gunfight in which Hernandez is shot, the abductor is killed and the girl is saved. The media gets wind of the story, and soon, the heroic Hernandez has become “the new ‘Poster Child’ of the FBI.” But while she is in the hospital recovering, someone attempts to murder Deerling. The young FBI agent quickly realizes that finding and stopping the serial killer isn’t the end of the case but the very beginning. Although this novel is powered by a cast of credible characters, brisk pacing and an impressively intricate storyline, Hernandez’s penchant for soliloquies is slightly annoying; her romantic connection to Deerling also feels contrived. But Hernandez—like Harris’ Clarice Starling—is a deeply intriguing and endearing protagonist who, according to the author, will return in a future novel.
Murder, meth and mystery in Montana. In a word: marvelous.