Clementine's liberation might have been something to cheer about back when Philadelphia society celebrated the Centennial in...

READ REVIEW

THE LIBERATION OF CLEMENTINE TIPTON

Clementine's liberation might have been something to cheer about back when Philadelphia society celebrated the Centennial in 1876. Nowadays the arrival of a strict but sensible governess -- replacing flighty, carping Mademoiselle -- isn't much to get excited about. And since Clementine, said to be a hoyden, is with one or two exceptions a model child, there's not much fun to speak of either. Clementine does chop her unruly red curls in a fit of self-assertion -- a symbolic act that's hardly original enough to pass as the climax of her liberation from Mademoiselle 200 pages earlier; her real function is to provide a child's eye view of the upstairs/downstairs Tipton household, which, tight down to the butler, the cook, and the climactic dinner party for Brazilian Emperor Dom Pedro, is a pale American copy of the TV original. Babyish.

Pub Date: Oct. 16, 1974

ISBN: N/A

Page Count: 214

Publisher: Houghton Mifflin

Review Posted Online: N/A

Kirkus Reviews Issue: Oct. 1, 1974

Close Quickview