THE JUDGE, An Untrue Tale by Harve Zemach
Kirkus Star

THE JUDGE, An Untrue Tale

Email this review


One after another, the prisoners are brought before the judge, crying ""A horrible thing is coming this way./ Creeping closer day by day./ Its eyes are scary/ Its tail is hairy/ I tell you, Judge, we all better pray!"" And one by one each is condemned as a liar, a half-wit, a scoundrel, a nincompoop. . . until talking ceases and justice is done: a ""horrible thing"" looks in the window, comes in the door, snaps up the judge. . . and gives the prisoners the freedom of the last page. The wordless resolution is a savvy use of Sendak, the text is a self-?propellant that kids will say in unison, the pictures bristle and tremble with the protagonists--it couldn't be more assured or sure to succeed.

Pub Date: Nov. 21st, 1969
Publisher: Farrar, Straus & Giroux