A loose, beautiful tapestry of a tale that would be more satisfying if woven tighter.
Prehistoric young warrior Quiller must choose between helping her best friend, Lynx, survive his spirit quest in the glacial wilderness or saving her newly formed family from the Rust People.
When lions attack Lynx’s camp, leaving only him alive, Quiller must convince the Sealion People elders that Lynx is not a coward who abandoned his people—for which the punishment is death. Nightbreaker, the lions' giant and unusually intelligent pride leader, seems to have protected Lynx during the attack, so Quiller argues that he must be a spirit helper with a quest for Lynx. Maybe he’s even the mysterious old man who appeared during and after the attack, in a different form. Her ploy works, and the elders abandon Lynx on the Ice Giants, huge glaciers, to seek Nightbreaker’s guidance or die trying. Lynx has never been good at hunting or battle, so Quiller promises to defy the elders and help him. Before she can, she finds four children in an enemy village ravaged by disease and predators. After adopting the Rust People children, she must choose between finding Lynx or protecting her new family. Meanwhile, despite almost dying several times, Lynx finds the mysterious old man Dr. John Arakie. He shows Lynx there’s truth to the old stories about gods leaving Earth and disappearing underground when the ice came but needs Lynx to become part of the story for humanity to survive. Gear brings her vast knowledge of prehistoric cultures to this climate-fiction tale with beautiful and engaging worldbuilding. However, there are many seemingly contradictory and confusing details that may make it hard for readers to find their footing early on. Just enough hints and promises of revelation are doled out—often in exposition thinly disguised as “there’s an old story that says...”— to make readers hang on for answers. However, the big reveal after the slow and meandering buildup isn’t much of a surprise and only adds more unanswered questions—all to set up a sequel.
A loose, beautiful tapestry of a tale that would be more satisfying if woven tighter.Pub Date: June 15, 2021
ISBN: 978-0-7564-1584-6
Page Count: 304
Publisher: DAW/Berkley
Review Posted Online: May 18, 2021
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 1, 2021
Both heartbreaking and action-packed: an immense achievement.
Two children are scouted as promising prospects for opposing magical syndicates in Lu’s urban fantasy.
Samantha Lang is the daughter of a Chinese immigrant working around the clock to make ends meet in Angel City, California. Her classmate Ari, a boy from Gujarat, India, seems to be the only person who really sees her. They pass each other notes, sharing their feelings but not the specifics of their lives. When Sam’s mother loses her job, Sam is so desperate that she seeks out the fabulously wealthy Diamond Taylor, a local celebrity who has a reputation for making things happen. Sam isn’t sure what to ask for, but it certainly isn’t what she gets: When she’s discovered following Diamond’s entourage out of a fancy theater, she finds herself initiated into the world of alchemy. As it turns out, there’s a secret society of people who are able to tap into the power of their own souls to transmute one substance into another. The popular drug called sand, which is known for making people the best version of themselves, is secretly a product of alchemy. Sand is worth so much money that syndicates—organized groups of alchemists—are in deep competition with each other to produce it. As Sam grows up, so do tensions between Diamond’s syndicate, Grand Central, and its main rival, Lumines. Years after their time passing notes in school, Sam and Ari discover that they have both been trained as alchemists, and they are on opposite sides of the upcoming war between Grand Central and Lumines. Lu’s magical system of alchemy is straightforward and clever—for example, a person can fight by transmuting a piece of a table into a knife, and they can hurt an enemy by transmuting the water in their body into vapor. But even more than the inventive action sequences, Lu beautifully depicts Sam and Ari’s experiences as outsiders in the world of wealth and privilege. Ari as an immigrant, and Sam as the daughter of an immigrant, both have a lot to lose, and their precarity is weaponized against them as they are weaponized against each other.
Both heartbreaking and action-packed: an immense achievement.Pub Date: Oct. 14, 2025
ISBN: 9781250885678
Page Count: 432
Publisher: Tor
Review Posted Online: Aug. 2, 2025
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 1, 2025
Intriguing worldbuilding can’t compensate for two-dimensional lead characters and a lackluster primary storyline.
The first installment of Stewart’s Hollow Covenant trilogy is set in a fantasy world where humans have destroyed the planet’s sustainability—and magic—and feuding gods do battle to restore the world.
After humans selfishly consume much of the magic on the planet, the Shattering changes everyone who lives in its various realms. Kluehnn—who called himself the “one true god”—makes a pact with his followers after hunting down and killing most of the other deities. He will systematically restore each realm back to its pristine environmental state, but half the population will be “altered to suit the new landscape.” The other half will be destroyed, their matter used to reshape the terrain. As the country of Kashan is being forcibly restored by a relentless black wall sweeping over the land, chaos ensues as people attempt to escape. Fifteen-year-old Hakara desperately tries to save herself and her little sister, Rasha, but they are separated in the turmoil. Hakara awakes safely in the neighboring realm, but her sister’s fate is unknown. An environmental cautionary tale blended with an impressively intricate fantasy backstory, the premise here is strong, as are the multiple intertwining storylines exploring a diversity of perspectives. The problem is with the major plot thread revolving around the two sisters’ search for one another—particularly Hakara’s obsession with crossing the barrier to the transformed Kashan to find Rasha, who may be dead or altered. The intensity is initially high, but it loses power quickly as secondary characters and storylines take over. Compared to fully realized and impressively complex characters like Thassir, an emotionally scarred god in disguise; Mullayne, an explorer in search of Unterra, the mythical subterranean home of the gods before the Shattering; and the courageous Sheuan Sim, who must use her wits and savvy to survive an impossible situation that puts her entire clan at risk, the sisters are unremarkable.
Intriguing worldbuilding can’t compensate for two-dimensional lead characters and a lackluster primary storyline.Pub Date: Sept. 3, 2024
ISBN: 9780316564892
Page Count: 528
Publisher: Orbit
Review Posted Online: Aug. 3, 2024
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 1, 2024
BOOK REVIEW
© Copyright 2025 Kirkus Media LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Follow
Popular in this Genre
We can’t wait for you to join Kirkus!
It’s free and takes less than 10 seconds!
Already have an account? Log in.
OR
Sign in with GoogleTrouble signing in? Retrieve credentials.
Welcome Back!
OR
Sign in with GoogleTrouble signing in? Retrieve credentials.
