A real-life judicial nightmare, effectively told.
In this debut true-crime book, former trial lawyer Nash meticulously presents her case that a high-profile Boston murder trial of a 15-year-old resulted in a miscarriage of justice.
In July 1995, Janet Downing, a 42-year-old divorced mother of four, was stabbed 98 times in her home. Eddie O’Brien, who was best friends with one of the victim’s sons, was the only suspect. According to Nash, he was “an emotional adolescent with no history of violence or antisocial behavior.” Despite the fact that the police found no blood on his clothes or person and couldn’t determine a motive, he was arrested. As O’Brien’s lawyer noted in his closing argument, the state’s case, which Nash investigates in painstaking detail here, was based on “twisted evidence, a compromised crime scene, and ruined lives.” It was also, according to the author, a case of political ambition that catapulted the district attorney, Tom Reilly, to the office of attorney general: “Eddie’s case became the catalyst that changed juvenile law in Massachusetts,” Nash writes, “and sent children to adult prisons for the rest of their natural lives.” The author isn’t an objective observer; during the trial, she was asked by the judge to serve as guardian ad litem for O’Brien—his “designated adult with whom Eddie could discuss…his legal representation.” She tries to answer two questions: who really murdered Janet Downing, and why O’Brien has spent more than half his life behind bars? Overall, Nash delivers a riveting, highly detailed procedural. She profiles all of the principals in the case, clearly explains juvenile law and courtroom procedure in layman’s terms, and records the trial and, in several appendices, its aftermath. Along the way, she lays out a compelling and ultimately convincing case for O’Brien’s innocence. One ray of hope, she reports, is that the famous Innocence Project, which takes on cases that it sees as miscarriages of justice, has accepted O’Brien’s. The “uphill climb of trying to overturn his conviction” would make for an excellent sequel—or is, at least, the stuff that Netflix documentaries, such as Making a Murderer, are made of.
A real-life judicial nightmare, effectively told.Pub Date: Nov. 22, 2016
ISBN: 978-1-942266-77-8
Page Count: 348
Publisher: WildBlue Press
Review Posted Online: Sept. 6, 2017
Review Program: Kirkus Indie
Dogged original research and superb narrative skills come together in this gripping account of pitiless evil.
Greed, depravity, and serial murder in 1920s Oklahoma.
During that time, enrolled members of the Osage Indian nation were among the wealthiest people per capita in the world. The rich oil fields beneath their reservation brought millions of dollars into the tribe annually, distributed to tribal members holding "headrights" that could not be bought or sold but only inherited. This vast wealth attracted the attention of unscrupulous whites who found ways to divert it to themselves by marrying Osage women or by having Osage declared legally incompetent so the whites could fleece them through the administration of their estates. For some, however, these deceptive tactics were not enough, and a plague of violent death—by shooting, poison, orchestrated automobile accident, and bombing—began to decimate the Osage in what they came to call the "Reign of Terror." Corrupt and incompetent law enforcement and judicial systems ensured that the perpetrators were never found or punished until the young J. Edgar Hoover saw cracking these cases as a means of burnishing the reputation of the newly professionalized FBI. Bestselling New Yorkerstaff writer Grann (The Devil and Sherlock Holmes: Tales of Murder, Madness, and Obsession, 2010, etc.) follows Special Agent Tom White and his assistants as they track the killers of one extended Osage family through a closed local culture of greed, bigotry, and lies in pursuit of protection for the survivors and justice for the dead. But he doesn't stop there; relying almost entirely on primary and unpublished sources, the author goes on to expose a web of conspiracy and corruption that extended far wider than even the FBI ever suspected. This page-turner surges forward with the pacing of a true-crime thriller, elevated by Grann's crisp and evocative prose and enhanced by dozens of period photographs.
Dogged original research and superb narrative skills come together in this gripping account of pitiless evil.Pub Date: April 18, 2017
ISBN: 978-0-385-53424-6
Page Count: 352
Publisher: Doubleday
Review Posted Online: Feb. 1, 2017
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 15, 2017
BOOK TO SCREEN
BOOK TO SCREEN
BOOK TO SCREEN
"There's got to be something wrong with somebody who'd do a thing like that." This is Perry Edward Smith, talking about himself. "Deal me out, baby...I'm a normal." This is Richard Eugene Hickock, talking about himself. They're as sick a pair as Leopold and Loeb and together they killed a mother, a father, a pretty 17-year-old and her brother, none of whom they'd seen before, in cold blood. A couple of days before they had bought a 100 foot rope to garrote them—enough for ten people if necessary. This small pogrom took place in Holcomb, Kansas, a lonesome town on a flat, limitless landscape: a depot, a store, a cafe, two filling stations, 270 inhabitants. The natives refer to it as "out there." It occurred in 1959 and Capote has spent five years, almost all of the time which has since elapsed, in following up this crime which made no sense, had no motive, left few clues—just a footprint and a remembered conversation. Capote's alternating dossier Shifts from the victims, the Clutter family, to the boy who had loved Nancy Clutter, and her best friend, to the neighbors, and to the recently paroled perpetrators: Perry, with a stunted child's legs and a changeling's face, and Dick, who had one squinting eye but a "smile that works." They had been cellmates at the Kansas State Penitentiary where another prisoner had told them about the Clutters—he'd hired out once on Mr. Clutter's farm and thought that Mr. Clutter was perhaps rich. And this is the lead which finally broke the case after Perry and Dick had drifted down to Mexico, back to the midwest, been seen in Kansas City, and were finally picked up in Las Vegas. The last, even more terrible chapters, deal with their confessions, the law man who wanted to see them hanged, back to back, the trial begun in 1960, the post-ponements of the execution, and finally the walk to "The Corner" and Perry's soft-spoken words—"It would be meaningless to apologize for what I did. Even inappropriate. But I do. I apologize." It's a magnificent job—this American tragedy—with the incomparable Capote touches throughout. There may never have been a perfect crime, but if there ever has been a perfect reconstruction of one, surely this must be it.
Pub Date: Jan. 7, 1965
ISBN: 0375507906
Page Count: 343
Publisher: Random House
Review Posted Online: Oct. 10, 2011
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 1, 1965
BOOK REVIEW
BOOK REVIEW
BOOK REVIEW
© Copyright 2025 Kirkus Media LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Follow
Popular in this Genre
We can’t wait for you to join Kirkus!
It’s free and takes less than 10 seconds!
Already have an account? Log in.
OR
Sign in with GoogleTrouble signing in? Retrieve credentials.
Welcome Back!
OR
Sign in with GoogleTrouble signing in? Retrieve credentials.
