FATAL VISION by Joe McGinniss
Kirkus Star


Email this review


At 4 A.M. one morning in 1970, at Fort Bragg, No. Carolina, the wife and two daughters of Jeffrey MacDonald--a young M.D. and Green Beret volunteer--were found beaten and stabbed to death; MacDonald, who was himself slightly wounded, claimed that a quartet of Manson-like cultists had overpowered him, killed his family. But, though MacDonald seemed an All-American model of the young husband/father/doctor/soldier, the Army investigators (epically clumsy in the case's first stages) believed he was guilty: hearings followed; the charges were dismissed; grand-jury proceedings began in the mid-1970s, largely because of the vengeance-crusade of MacDonald's father-in-law; finally, in 1979, MacDonald (now a successful California M.D.) was brought to actual trial. And he asked McGinniss (The Selling of the President 1968, Going to Extremes) to write the full story, with first-hand coverage of the trial and first-person testimony from MacDonald himself. Here, then, is McGinniss' documentary-like chronicle of the case--alternating with the suspect's chatty, spookily banal reminiscences of his life up through the 1970s. The bulk of the 700-page text consists of interrogation/hearing/trial transcripts (180 solid pages of Grand Jury testimony alone). McGinniss is invisible as a character, almost invisible as a writer--with little or no description of physical appearances, the surroundings, personalities. Still, for readers willing to wade through the repetitious transcript detail (on physical evidence) and the air-headed MacDonald memoirs, there is a slow, strong fascination to McGinniss' impassive assemblage: the growing impression of MacDonald's lack of genuine emotions (except anger at the investigators); conflicts in testimony that highlight MacDonald's lies (about his infidelities, his marriage); accumulating hints of mental disturbance--from family comments as well as the often-unimpressive psychiatric testimony; bits of seemingly irrelevant information that later take on importance (e.g., the fact that Mrs. MacDonald was at an adult-ed class in child psychology the evening before the killings); and, perhaps most crucially, an implicit sense of McGinniss' own shifting back-and-forth about MacDonald's guilt. Only in the last chapters, however, does McGinniss emerge from the shadows--recording the 1979 defense-team's strategies ("Paint it monstrous because we don't have a monstrous defendant"), receiving bitter post-conviction letters from the imprisoned MacDonald, and coming up with a psycho-diagnosis of this unlikely murderer: "pathological narcissism," aggravated by amphetamines, with latent homosexuality, an obsession with macho-masculinity, and a "fatal vision" (idealized, secretly fearful) of women. (The consensus-theory is that MacDonald's wife made a psychologically threatening remark, he struck her in anger, and the violence escalated--with the children's deaths as part of a panicky coverup.) The analysis is too little, too late. The acres of transcript-material will put off all but the most devoted courtroom/crime buffs. But, if not in a league (by a long shot) with such crime-reconstructions as In Cold Blood and The Executioner's Song, this is a rigorous, journalistic approach to strange, engrossing material--and grimly rewarding for the patient, observant reader.
Pub Date: Sept. 16th, 1983
ISBN: 0451165667
Page count: 718pp
Publisher: Putnam
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 1st, 1983


NonfictionTHE ROGUE by Joe McGinniss
by Joe McGinniss
by Joe McGinniss
NonfictionTHE LAST BROTHER by Joe McGinniss
by Joe McGinniss


MysteryBROKEN ANGELS by Graham Masterton
by Graham Masterton
IndieDO YOU KNOW HOW TO FLY? by Gordon Kuhn
by Gordon Kuhn