UNDER EARTH, UNDER WATER by Aleksandra Mizielinska

UNDER EARTH, UNDER WATER

Age Range: 9 - 12
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

On oversized pages, top-to-bottom journeys through first our planet and then its oceans.

As itineraries go, neither outing is particularly well-organized. The land portion begins with clusters of nematodes and suchlike small subsurface dwellers—all accompanied by labels and, often, a descriptive comment—and goes on to teeming galleries of other diggers, including row after row of root vegetables. A series of human-built works in cross section follows, and then the book digs past plate tectonics to plunge into the mantle and so down to the planet’s core. In a switch that makes more poetic than physical sense, the orientation then reverses, so that turning the page begins a journey from the bottom of the Marianas Trench on up. That progress isn’t any steadier, as artificially dense crowds of exotic deep-sea fish give way to oil rigs and undersea vessels of diverse design, then finally select reef and freshwater-lake denizens. The unwieldy volume comes with two title pages (and covers), so voyagers can start from either end. Either way, though, the going takes on a monotonous quality, as the hundreds of creatures and structures are drawn in the same flat, cartoon style (rarely to scale) and so shoveled-in among balloons of commentary that many spreads look overstuffed. The skin tones of human figures vary from white to light brown.

A geo-hodgepodge, wearisome despite its planetary scope and a resolutely international outlook. (Informational picture book. 9-12)

Pub Date: Oct. 11th, 2016
ISBN: 978-1-78370-364-7
Page count: 112pp
Publisher: Big Picture/Candlewick
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 1st, 2016




MORE BY ALEKSANDRA MIZIELINSKA

ChildrenTHE WORLD OF MAMOKO IN THE YEAR 3000 by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska
ChildrenMAPS by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska
ChildrenWELCOME TO MAMOKO by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska

MORE BY DANIEL MIZIELINSKI

ChildrenTHE WORLD OF MAMOKO IN THE YEAR 3000 by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska
ChildrenMAPS by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska
ChildrenWELCOME TO MAMOKO by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska

MORE BY ALEKSANDRA MIZIELINSKA

ChildrenTHE WORLD OF MAMOKO IN THE YEAR 3000 by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska
ChildrenMAPS by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska
ChildrenWELCOME TO MAMOKO by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska

MORE BY DANIEL MIZIELINSKI

ChildrenTHE WORLD OF MAMOKO IN THE YEAR 3000 by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska
ChildrenMAPS by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska
ChildrenWELCOME TO MAMOKO by Aleksandra Mizielinska
by Aleksandra Mizielinska

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenILLUMINATURE by Carnovsky
by Carnovsky
ChildrenTHE OPEN OCEAN by Francesco Pittau
by Francesco Pittau
ChildrenTIMELINE by Peter Goes
by Peter Goes