NOBODY'S PERFECT by David Elliott

NOBODY'S PERFECT

by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 3 - 6
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Nobody’s perfect, and that’s actually fine.

A boy sits on the bottom step of an indoor staircase musing about imperfections. His baby sister, Gigi, is loud. His best friend, Jack, is “kind of a show-off.” His mother won’t listen when he insists that the dog’s habit of sleeping on his bed should be blamed on the dog. That last disagreement explains why he’s sitting here, in a timeout. His own imperfection, he thinks, is messiness: His room has toys everywhere and drawers bursting open. After he cleans, it’s demonstrably worse—the drawers have leaped free of the dressers, and the floor is nigh impassable. But messiness is key to joy and artwork, Jack’s showing off is fun when it’s playful, and Gigi’s clamor enables thrilling, pot-banging screamfests. The boy forgives his mom’s supposed flaw too, but he doesn’t reframe it—she’s OK because “[s]ometimes she does listen,” not because her trait is sometimes a boon. This uneasy break in the pattern dilutes the interesting point that flaws aren’t always flaws. Zuppardi’s loose, scribbly, deceptively child-styled pencil outlines vibrate with energy, and his colorful acrylic backgrounds feature uninhibitedly visible brush strokes, drips, splotches and lines made from pulling a tool through wet paint. The kids have enormous heads; their wide-open mouths are unabashedly colored in with gray pencil.

Not the most fascinating or consistent storyline, but snazzy artwork spruces it up. (Picture book. 3-6)

Pub Date: Feb. 10th, 2015
ISBN: 978-0-7636-6699-6
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Candlewick
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 15th, 2014




MORE BY DAVID ELLIOTT

ChildrenIN THE PAST by David Elliott
by David Elliott
ChildrenBAABWAA AND WOOLIAM by David Elliott
by David Elliott
ChildrenBULL by David Elliott
by David Elliott

MORE BY SAM ZUPPARDI

ChildrenTHINGS TO DO WITH DAD by Sam Zuppardi
by Sam Zuppardi
ChildrenJACK'S WORRY by Sam Zuppardi
by Sam Zuppardi
ChildrenTHE PET AND THE PENDULUM by Gordon McAlpine
by Gordon McAlpine

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenI AM OTTER by Sam Garton
by Sam Garton
ChildrenPERFECT PETUNIAS by Lynn Jenkins
by Lynn Jenkins
ChildrenJUST LIKE I WANTED by Elinoar Keller
by Elinoar Keller