BLACK DIAMOND & BLAKE by Deborah Blumenthal


by and illustrated by
Age Range: 5 - 8
Email this review


Black Diamond, a fictional champion racehorse, goes to a prison equine rehabilitation center after a career-ending injury, in this tale inspired by real-life prison programs. A young inmate, Blake, befriends him, and—happily-ever-after—adopts Black Diamond upon his own release. Unfortunately, Blumenthal’s black-or-white attitude stacks the narrative deck: Black Diamond is a champion racehorse, not an ordinary one; a sinister man “with a fat wallet” tries to buy Black Diamond before the rehab program does (why would this be bad?); the prisoners other than Blake treat Black Diamond harshly (so the rehab program is inhumane?); Blake is in prison for stealing money to help his out-of-work father support the family (only prisoners with noble motives are worthwhile?). These extremes manipulate readers’ emotions without presenting a realistic picture of such programs for readers. Overly sentimental third-person narration in Black Diamond’s voice includes such clunky lines as “in a minute that grew heavy with time.” Hyman’s lovely pastels provide a 1950s feel, which seems at odds with the modernity of the rehab programs. (author’s note) (Picture book. 5-8)

Pub Date: Feb. 10th, 2009
ISBN: 978-0-375-84003-6
Page count: 40pp
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 15th, 2009


ChildrenFANCY PARTY GOWNS by Deborah Blumenthal
by Deborah Blumenthal
ChildrenHURRICANE KISS by Deborah Blumenthal
by Deborah Blumenthal
ChildrenMAFIA GIRL by Deborah Blumenthal
by Deborah Blumenthal
ChildrenTHE LIFEGUARD by Deborah Blumenthal
by Deborah Blumenthal
ChildrenCHARLIE HITS IT BIG by Deborah Blumenthal
by Deborah Blumenthal


ChildrenJULIA MORGAN BUILT A CASTLE by Celeste Davidson Mannis
by Celeste Davidson Mannis
Children9 MAGIC WISHES by Shirley Jackson
by Shirley Jackson
ChildrenBROADWAY CHICKEN by Jean-Luc Fromenthal
by Jean-Luc Fromenthal