by , illustrated by
Age Range: 4 - 7
Email this review


An extra-large take on the classic fairy tale.

The Warty Sisters, Cinderelephant’s warthog cousins, work the poor elephant mercilessly—in the first illustration, she has a pot handle in one hand and a mop in the other, and there’s an iron at the end of her trunk—and leave her sad and lonely when they depart for Prince Trunky’s ball. But a swish of her Furry Godmouse’s tail instantly transforms Cinderelephant’s clothes and makes a limo appear. Of course, she becomes the belle of the ball, as Prince Trunky is afraid of squashing the other, smaller guests. Indeed, synonyms for “large” dot the text. Some wordplay will go right over readers’ heads: “Cinder-irrelevant!” But other instances will be in tune with a kid’s sense of humor, as when the Furry Godmouse tells Cinderelephant to have a good time, but, “and it’s a big but.” This is juxtaposed with an illustration of Cinderelephant’s huge derrière as she bends down to get into the white stretch limo. Unfortunately, though, while the illustrations have moments of humor, they don’t otherwise stand out; despite Dodd’s oversized subject, the details often get lost in the digital artwork, and the sparkly cover, while it may attract readers, isn’t enough to keep them coming back. And why, with all the possibilities available to her, does Dodd limit herself to names so unfunny and -punny?

Other fractured versions are funnier, while many straightforward versions are far more beautiful; opt for them. (Fractured fairy tale. 4-7)

Pub Date: Oct. 1st, 2013
ISBN: 978-0-545-53285-3
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Levine/Scholastic
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 15th, 2013


ChildrenBABY AND ME by Emma Dodd
by Emma Dodd
ChildrenFOXY IN LOVE by Emma Dodd
by Emma Dodd
ChildrenFOREVER by Emma Dodd
by Emma Dodd
ChildrenI LOVE MY DADDY by Giles Andreae
by Giles Andreae
ChildrenI AM SMALL by Emma Dodd
by Emma Dodd


ChildrenCINDERELLA by K.Y. Craft
by K.Y. Craft
ChildrenCINDERS by Jan Brett
by Jan Brett
ChildrenCINDERELLA by Barbara McClintock
by Barbara McClintock