A PROMISE IS A PROMISE by Florence Parry Heide

A PROMISE IS A PROMISE

by , illustrated by
Age Range: 6 - 8

KIRKUS REVIEW

In this uninspired take on a tired premise, young George wangles permission from his parents for a pet, then brings home a series of unsuitable ones. Ordered to take back the huge dog, the breeding pair of mice and the shark, George extracts a promise that he can have a bird—and so he gets a big, bright red, loudly abusive parrot. Spoiled and sullen, George makes an unappealing protagonist, his clueless dad and wimpy, hand-wringing mother show not a speck of intelligence and the sketchy, rumpled figures in Auth’s illustrations supply neither character nor much humor. There is no reason to prefer this over (to name a few examples) Dan Yaccarino’s An Octopus Followed Me Home (1997), Lauren Child’s I Want a Pet (1999) or Karen Kaufman Orloff’s I Wanna Iguana (2004), illustrated by David Catrow. (Picture book. 6-8)

Pub Date: May 1st, 2007
ISBN: 978-0-7636-2285-5
Page count: 40pp
Publisher: Candlewick
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: May 1st, 2007




MORE BY FLORENCE PARRY HEIDE

ChildrenMYSTERY AT BLUE RIDGE CEMETERY by Roxanne Heide Pierce
by Roxanne Heide Pierce
ChildrenDILLWEED'S REVENGE by Florence Parry Heide
by Florence Parry Heide
ChildrenALWAYS LISTEN TO YOUR MOTHER by Florence Parry Heide
by Florence Parry Heide

MORE BY TONY AUTH

ChildrenUNCLE PIRATE TO THE RESCUE by Douglas Rees
by Douglas Rees
ChildrenUNCLE PIRATE by Douglas Rees
by Douglas Rees
ChildrenMY CURIOUS UNCLE DUDLEY by Barry Yourgrau
by Barry Yourgrau