A PLAN FOR POPS by Heather Smith

A PLAN FOR POPS

by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 3 - 8
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

Lou visits Grandad and Pops every Saturday and learns a lot from their radically alternative interests, until an accident disrupts the family’s happy routine.

Grandad likes learning how things work, and Pops enjoys the spicier things in life. Lou continually goes between them, equally validating their perspectives. Once Pops is asleep after listening to rock-and-roll, Lou and Grandad work on perfecting their (unnamed) Rube Goldberg machine that produces an aerial burst of paper cranes. One Saturday, Pops, already frail, suffers a fall, after which he must permanently use a wheelchair. Over the following weeks, Lou takes up the mission of getting a depressed Pops to come out of his room. Smith conscientiously relates how “the three Ps—perseverance, persistence and patience”—apply to many aspects of life. Kerrigan’s digital art couples quick pencil outlines with gentle and colorful watercolor washes, subtly mirroring the two grandparents’ personalities. Facial expressions and body language convey mood well. On the page turn when Pops falls, Kerrigan utilizes minimalism to successfully convey the incident and the sharp emotion it elicits. The ending is happily resolved but abrupt. Rachel Martinez’s translation for the companion French edition, Une idée pour Papi, is mostly verbatim but edits to two Ps, “la persévérance et la patience,” forgiven perhaps with the three words’ similar meanings, even in English. Granddad presents black and both Pops and Lou present white.

A positive and realistic representation of both a wheelchair user and an elderly, interracial gay male couple. (Picture book. 3-8)

Pub Date: Feb. 19th, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-4598-1614-5
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Orca
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Dec. 1st, 2018




MORE BY HEATHER SMITH

ChildrenANGUS ALL AGLOW by Heather Smith
by Heather Smith
ChildrenTHE AGONY OF BUN O'KEEFE by Heather Smith
by Heather Smith
ChildrenBAYGIRL by Heather Smith
by Heather Smith

MORE BY BROOKE KERRIGAN

ChildrenTHE CHRISTMAS WIND by Stephanie Simpson McLellan
by Stephanie Simpson McLellan
ChildrenJAMMIE DAY! by Carrie Snyder
by Carrie Snyder
ChildrenLITTLE BOY WHO LIVED DOWN THE DRAIN by Carolyn Huizinga  Mills
by Carolyn Huizinga Mills

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenKING FOR A DAY by Rukhsana Khan
by Rukhsana Khan
ChildrenLITTLE PIG SAVES THE SHIP by David Hyde Costello
by David Hyde Costello
ChildrenLOOP THE LOOP by Barbara Dugan
by Barbara Dugan