IT'S NOT THE PUPPY by J. Patrick Lewis

IT'S NOT THE PUPPY

Age Range: 1 - 3
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

The big-eyed pup on the cover of this board book is obviously a scamp and quite possibly to blame for all sorts of mayhem—or maybe not.

Each page shows a different character engaged in some activity, often mischievous, that might be expected from a dog, but the picture and text clearly indicate otherwise. The actual culprits are not named, and not all are animals. They include a bunny, raccoon, cat, and three children. Young children will quickly pick up the refrain, “It’s not the puppy?”—the proper response to the unobtrusively rhyming question posed on each left-hand page. The language is clear and direct: “When he waves his furry tail, / who knocks down the garbage pail?” The lively, cartoon illustrations include plenty of related details—flowers in the garden where the bunny digs, flies buzzing around the garbage can a raccoon has raided. Unfortunately, the pictures of children tend to reinforce gender stereotypes with what appears to be boys having active roles—tracking in mud while chasing a ball and practicing “doggy paddles in the tub.” The only child textually identified by gender is a girl hiding from thunder. The final picture is of another, less-fearful pigtailed child waking to “a big wet kiss surprise… / it IS the puppy!” All children depicted have brown skin and curly black hair.

Don’t expect kids to pause to identify the mischief-makers or talk about the pictures, at least at first—do expect a request to “read it again.” (Board book. 1-3)

Pub Date: March 12th, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-68152-409-2
Page count: 14pp
Publisher: Amicus Ink
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Feb. 15th, 2019




MORE BY J. PATRICK LEWIS

ChildrenTHE POETRY OF US by J. Patrick Lewis
by J. Patrick Lewis
ChildrenLAST LAUGHS by J. Patrick Lewis
by J. Patrick Lewis
ChildrenTHE NAVAJO CODE TALKERS by J. Patrick Lewis
by J. Patrick Lewis

MORE BY MADDIE FROST

ChildrenROW, ROW, ROW YOUR BOAT by Maddie Frost
by Maddie Frost
ChildrenA IS FOR ARTICHOKE by America's Test Kitchen
by America's Test Kitchen

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenLET'S GO OUTSIDE by Kate Riggs
by Kate Riggs
ChildrenPUPPY TALK by J.C. Coates
by J.C. Coates
ChildrenLOIS LOOKS FOR BOB AT HOME by Nosy Crow
by Nosy Crow