PAPER DAUGHTER by Jeanette Ingold

PAPER DAUGHTER

Age Range: 12 & up

KIRKUS REVIEW

Maggie Chen, 16, an intern at a Seattle newspaper who is grieving her journalist father’s recent death, is shocked to discover that he fabricated his family history. A smart, ambitious journalist in the making, Maggie sets out to discover why he lied, what happened to his—and her—real family and a possible link between his death and the government corruption case her newspaper is investigating. Interwoven with Maggie’s engaging narrative is the story of Chinese twins Fai-yi and Sucheng Li. In a flashback to 1932, Fai-yi recalls how they entered the United States using a “paper father,” a ruse to circumvent draconian laws prohibiting Chinese immigration. As the narratives merge, however, readers learn that responsibility for decades of loss and family alienation lies not with those events—Chinese poverty prompting mass emigration, brutal immigration laws harshly applied—but with one irredeemably evil character. Because evil is ahistorical, a cause rather than an effect, this motivation trivializes the novel’s context, rendering it largely irrelevant. Lacking ties to character motivation and choices, even the accurate historical detail rendered here is reduced to cultural wallpaper. (Historical fiction. 12 & up)

Pub Date: April 1st, 2010
ISBN: 978-0-15-205507-3
Page count: 176pp
Publisher: Harcourt
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 15th, 2010




MODERN CHINESE-AMERICAN KIDS IN FICTION:

Children CELIA’S ROBOT by Margaret Chang
by Margaret Chang
Children HONEYSUCKLE HOUSE by Andrea Cheng
by Andrea Cheng
Children PAPER DAUGHTER by Jeanette Ingold
by Jeanette Ingold
Children THE YEAR OF THE DOG by Grace Lin
by Grace Lin

MORE BY JEANETTE INGOLD

ChildrenHITCH by Jeanette Ingold
by Jeanette Ingold
ChildrenMOUNTAIN SOLO by Jeanette Ingold
by Jeanette Ingold
ChildrenTHE BIG BURN by Jeanette Ingold
by Jeanette Ingold

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionFRENCH TWIST by Catherine Crawford
by Catherine Crawford