Well-meaning, but for a more genuine cognitively disabled protagonist, pair with Sharon Flake’s Pinned (2012)
A 12-year-old English girl with Down syndrome copes with drama in her tightknit family over a stormy Easter.
Darby loves her mother and her stepbrother, Olly, and her stepdad. She loves the strawberry farm where she lives. She loves music and paint by numbers. But more than anything else, she adores her 16-year-old sister, Kaydee. Darby’s jealous of her sister’s attention, so she is anything but pleased when Kaydee’s best friend, Lissa, comes for the weekend. At least this weekend will feature one of Darby’s favorite events, when she and her family find chocolate eggs in the yard. But with high winds spawning tornadoes and threatening their greenhouses, her parents are distracted and miserable. When Darby sees Kaydee and Lissa kissing and then tells Olly what she’s seen, he gets weird. Darby’s point of view as a cognitively disabled protagonist is a welcome one, though the execution is flawed; in one scene she describes dialogue she explicitly tells readers she was unable to hear. Moreover, though Darby’s a whole and interesting person, by the conclusion she’s been diminished to a tired trope of Down syndrome innocence, healing all wounds through pure insights about love. “Oh, Darby.…What would we do without you, eh?” her dad asks whenever the childlike innocence of her Down syndrome causes a shift in his perspective.
Well-meaning, but for a more genuine cognitively disabled protagonist, pair with Sharon Flake’s Pinned (2012) . (Fiction. 9-12)Pub Date: March 5, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-4998-0838-4
Page Count: 240
Publisher: Little Bee Books
Review Posted Online: Dec. 15, 2018
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Jan. 15, 2019
BOOK REVIEW
BOOK REVIEW
Please don’t go, Penderwicks; it’s too soon to say goodbye.
The beloved family is back—and taking their final bow.
In this fifth and final title in the endearing series, the spotlight is on the youngest sibling, now-11-year-old Lydia, would-be dancer. Everyone’s gearing up for the wedding of eldest sister Rosalind, scrambling to ensure the happy couple can get hitched without a hitch at Arundel, the imposing estate where the Penderwick saga began (The Penderwicks, 2005). Thrown into the mix is an older brother who’s aspiring to be a film director; riotous animals, including a stair-climbing chicken and an independent-minded sheep; and snooty interference from the estate’s former owner. Lydia meets a new gal pal; gets embroiled in the arrangements of what eventually evolves into a double wedding; and emerges as her own winning personality. As in the other series titles, Birdsall writes with a knowing, breezy hand and infuses cozy, old-fashioned, humorous warmth into the proceedings while adhering to a white default. Occasionally, Lydia comes across as younger than her years. Still, readers will appreciate the younger girl’s antics and the numerous musical references (which threaten to date the novel) and will likely swoon over the wedding details, some unrealistic. Certainly, die-hard fans will rejoice that the author virtually promises that two very popular characters will wed several years hence. Is an encore to come?
Please don’t go, Penderwicks; it’s too soon to say goodbye. (Fiction. 9-12)Pub Date: May 15, 2018
ISBN: 978-0-385-75566-5
Page Count: 304
Publisher: Knopf
Review Posted Online: March 17, 2018
Kirkus Reviews Issue: April 1, 2018
BOOK REVIEW
BOOK REVIEW
BOOK REVIEW
Well-intentioned but simplistic.
An exploration of antisemitism and racism in a small-town middle school grappling with an incident of graffitied swastikas.
Debut author Kramaroff presents an appealing protagonist in sixth grader Josh, the only Jewish kid in his school, who is coming to terms with claiming his identity in the face of heavy-handed antisemitic slurs and actions, like tossing coins at his feet and calling him “a dirty jew.” The accessible verse, written almost entirely in lowercase, follows Josh’s awakening to the cause of justice as his almost entirely White and Christian school responds to the transgressions. Regrettably, Josh and his school community conflate justice with kindness, resulting in adulation when Josh founds the Do More Club, which combats hate through affirming sticky notes and kindness rocks. Underdeveloped side characters serve to teach Josh about his privilege and portray him as a mensch. When seventh grader Marcus, the only Black kid in school, experiences a similar racial attack, Josh discovers that anti-Blackness is more pervasive than he’d realized, but Kramaroff does not afford Marcus the agency to react outside of Josh’s framework. In addition to his caring Do More crew, Josh receives support from a rabbi who explains tikkun olam—the Jewish concept of repairing the world—as well as from the school’s lone Black teacher. Unfortunately, neither pushes Josh—or readers—to consider a more robust, systemic understanding of justice and equity.
Well-intentioned but simplistic. (Verse fiction. 9-12)Pub Date: Aug. 29, 2023
ISBN: 9780593532874
Page Count: 256
Publisher: Rocky Pond Books/Penguin
Review Posted Online: May 9, 2023
Kirkus Reviews Issue: June 1, 2023
© Copyright 2026 Kirkus Media LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Follow
Popular in this Genre
We can’t wait for you to join Kirkus!
It’s free and takes less than 10 seconds!
Already have an account? Log in.
OR
Sign in with GoogleTrouble signing in? Retrieve credentials.
Welcome Back!
OR
Sign in with GoogleTrouble signing in? Retrieve credentials.
