THE JUST CITY by Jo Walton

THE JUST CITY

Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

What happens when the goddess Athene tries to establish Plato's Republic on Atlantis, populated with a few hundred philosophers plucked from 2,500 years of history, more than 10,000 manumitted slave children and a handful of robot workers?

For some reason, Plato is not invited, but Socrates is welcome, as are a number of Plato's translators and devotees, including Plotinus and Cicero. The adults, known as “masters,” are generally happy to build the Just City, but not all the children are, especially since it’s strongly implied that the masters encouraged the growth of slavery in various eras by purchasing so many children. And although the children are well-treated and educated, they're not allowed to leave and must follow strict rules whose provenance they can’t entirely understand, since they’re not even allowed to read The Republic. The justness of the City becomes even more questionable when evidence accumulates that the mechanical workers used in place of slaves may actually be sentient. There’s more thought experiment than plot here. The fictional and mythological protagonists have a certain appeal, but it’s disappointing that Walton (Among Others, 2011, etc.) barely sketches most of the historical characters who play minor roles in the story—readers will have to do the research themselves in order to flesh them out.

This is novel as study guide: Mary Renault meets undergraduate Philosophy 101.

Pub Date: Jan. 1st, 2015
ISBN: 978-0-7653-3266-0
Page count: 368pp
Publisher: Tor
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Nov. 1st, 2014




MORE BY JO WALTON

Sci-FiSTARLINGS by Jo Walton
by Jo Walton
Sci-FiNECESSITY by Jo Walton
by Jo Walton
Sci-FiTHE PHILOSOPHER KINGS by Jo Walton
by Jo Walton

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

Sci-FiKAREN MEMORY by Elizabeth Bear
by Elizabeth Bear
FictionANNIHILATION by Jeff VanderMeer
by Jeff VanderMeer
FictionGIBBON'S DECLINE AND FALL by Sheri S. Tepper
by Sheri S. Tepper