WE WANT TO NEGOTIATE by Joel Simon

WE WANT TO NEGOTIATE

The Secret World of Kidnapping, Hostages and Ransom
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A well-formed argument against the doctrine of refusing to negotiate with terrorists to gain the release of hostages.

“From a pure negotiating standpoint,” writes Simon (The New Censorship: Inside the Global Battle for Media Freedom, 2015, etc.), executive director of the Committee to Protect Journalists, “adopting a public posture of ‘we don’t negotiate with terrorists’ is a terrible opening gambit.” First formulated by Richard Nixon, that posture reduces the value of the hostages to their kidnappers, which makes it more likely that hostages will be killed. Still, talking tough in the face of hostage-takers scores political points in the U.S. and the U.K. even as countries such as France pay in order to rescue their citizens. Again, that’s for political reasons. As Simon notes, when war correspondent Florence Aubenas was kidnapped in Iraq in 2005, the French government reportedly paid $10 million to retrieve her. Officially, the government denied that it had acquiesced, but the fact that it had underscores political differences: “When French citizens are kidnapped, the public often mobilizes to demand their release,” with the idea that part of the social contract is that the government protects its citizenry by whatever means necessary. On the other hand, Americans and Brits come with guns blazing, which often leads to the deaths of hostages, if not soldiers and civilian bystanders. As Simon observes, when the British sent in soldiers to rescue a New York Times correspondent and a colleague taken hostage in Afghanistan, a soldier, a woman, and a child died in the fire. “These deaths,” he notes, “were all the more tragic because private negotiators who were communicating with the kidnappers already had a deal for both hostages’ release.” Simon, who has been involved in negotiation efforts himself, ventures that Daniel Pearl’s killing in Pakistan might have been avoidable and that it was meant to send a signal “that kidnapping Westerners was now a sanctioned tactic" on the part of al-Qaida.

A persuasive argument that deserves to be heard in Foggy Bottom, the Pentagon, and other corridors of power.

Pub Date: Jan. 8th, 2019
ISBN: 978-0-9997454-2-7
Page count: 170pp
Publisher: Columbia Global Reports
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Oct. 15th, 2018




MORE BY JOEL SIMON

NonfictionTHE NEW CENSORSHIP by Joel Simon
by Joel Simon
NonfictionENDANGERED MEXICO by Joel Simon
by Joel Simon

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionTHE INVITATION-ONLY ZONE by Robert S. Boynton
by Robert S. Boynton
NonfictionNO TURNING BACK by Rania Abouzeid
by Rania Abouzeid
NonfictionTHE HOSTAGE'S DAUGHTER by Sulome Anderson
by Sulome Anderson