OLD MACDONALD HAD HER FARM by JonArno Lawson

OLD MACDONALD HAD HER FARM

by , illustrated by
Age Range: 5 - 8

KIRKUS REVIEW

A new take on the old song highlights the role of vowels in the English language.

“Old MacDonald had her farm, / a e i o u. / And when she came across an a, / this is what she’d do:  / Saw barn planks, stack sacks….” Youngsters will never mistake this for the familiar song, especially when they attempt to read the tongue-twisting, nearly nonsense text aloud. Lawson’s giddily flowing style just doesn’t adapt well to this grammar lesson. The garish computer-generated art complements the silly tone by showing Old MacDonald fiddling with a Rube Goldberg–type contraption for sawing and stacking on the “a” page and continuing her over-the-top farm chores on the succeeding ones. There is really no story here, just a jumble of words that demonstrate the various sounds that each vowel can make. However, readers and listeners will enjoy following the action on each page right until the end, when Mr. and Mrs. MacDonald seem to settle down into a rowdy song with all their animals singing along. Teachers might find this helpful when working on vowels, and children will enjoy making lists of words that rhyme with the words in the story. No one will mistake this for anything other than a school exercise.

High-energy ride to nowhere. (Picture book. 5-8)

Pub Date: Oct. 1st, 2012
ISBN: 978-1-55451-457-1
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Annick Press
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Sept. 15th, 2012




MORE BY TINA HOLDCROFT

ChildrenWHAT THE SNAKES WROTE by Hazel Hutchins
by Hazel Hutchins
ChildrenSPY, SPY AGAIN by Tina Holdcroft
by Tina Holdcroft
ChildrenKIDS AT THE CROSSROADS: AZTEC by Laura Scandiffio
by Laura Scandiffio

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenHI! FLY GUY by Tedd Arnold
by Tedd Arnold
ChildrenRHYMING DUST BUNNIES by Jan Thomas
by Jan Thomas
ChildrenTHE CAT ON THE MAT IS FLAT by Andy Griffiths
by Andy Griffiths