ABOVE by Leah Bobet


Age Range: 14 & up
Email this review


In a world where "Sick's the same as Freak Above," only below is Safe.

Safe is both adjective and noun in Matthew’s world, both the feeling and the subterranean haven built by claw-handed Atticus. Matthew is the Teller of Safe, the person who keeps everyone's stories and retells them. Its denizens are those unwanted Above: the mentally ill, the marginal—and the Cursed. He loves the fragile, honey-haired Ariel, whom he found on patrol in the sewers around Safe and who turns into a honeybee when under stress. Bobet starts her surreal fable/adventure explosively, with a catastrophic raid by the terrifying shadows that kills leader Atticus and scatters Safe's residents. Matthew, Ariel and two others make their way alone to a sympathetic doctor Above to regroup and, they hope, retake Safe. Above, Matthew finds his received history continually under challenge. Having been the first child born in Safe, Matthew sees it as the only reality. Occasionally interspersing Matthew's tightly filtered, present-tense account with the Tales of Safe, the author rarely gives readers an opportunity to see what may be objectively "real," making for a slightly claustrophobic, normality-inverting experience.

While readers who long for concrete answers may be frustrated, those willing to go along with this captivating exploration of both individual and collective identity will find themselves pondering its implications long after the last page. (Fiction. 14 & up)

Pub Date: April 1st, 2012
ISBN: 978-0-545-29670-0
Page count: 368pp
Publisher: Levine/Scholastic
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: March 15th, 2012


ChildrenA BREATH OF EYRE by Eve Marie Mont
by Eve Marie Mont
ChildrenRADIANT DAYS by Elizabeth Hand
by Elizabeth Hand
ChildrenBLACK HEART by Holly Black
by Holly Black
ChildrenTHE WICKED AND THE JUST by J. Anderson Coats
by J. Anderson Coats


ChildrenWONDER SHOW by Hannah Barnaby
by Hannah Barnaby
ChildrenSHADOWSHAPER by Daniel José Older
by Daniel José Older
ChildrenOUR DARK DUET  by Victoria Schwab
by Victoria Schwab