THE BIG EARTH BOOK by Mark Brake

THE BIG EARTH BOOK

From the "Lonely Planet Kids" series
by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 10 - 13
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A view of our planet and our place on it in terms of the four classical elements: earth, air, fire, and water.

It’s not a very strong conceit—showing strain almost immediately as the “Earth” section begins with the observation that 30 percent of our “rocky” home is actually oxygen—but for each of the four elements the author offers 29 double-page–spread introductions to a wide array of at least indirectly related topics. These range from surveys of the Earth’s hot interior and changing surface to the origins of life and of such technological wonders as cast-iron stoves as well as the golden ages both of exploration and of piracy, types of waterfalls, major historical fires, and what it might be like to live underwater. The authors add crunchy bits to this browser’s banquet by giving Gustav Whitehead pride of place over the Wright brothers as the first to fly, including the recently discovered Hamza (which flows more than two miles beneath the Amazon) in their tally of big rivers, and other surprises. Still, along with underseasoned elements including a reference to “the freezing part of the outer solar system” and a timeline point quaintly labeled “Man evolves,” Brake’s claim that in the wake of Columbus “people who’d never met due to being separated by the seas could now interact just as we all do today!” introduces, to say the least, a historically disingenuous sour note. Likewise less-than-palatable are Kearney’s cartoon renditions of pirates, ancient and prehistoric people, and modern figures as, with only rare exceptions (and those mostly in the occasional photos), white—one notable exception is a group of Navajo fire dancers portrayed as identical brown lads in loincloths.

An almost savory assemblage that’s spoiled by too many stale ingredients. (index, annotated bibliography) (Nonfiction. 10-13)

Pub Date: Nov. 21st, 2017
ISBN: 978-1-78701-278-3
Page count: 256pp
Publisher: Lonely Planet
Review Posted Online:




MORE BY BRENDAN KEARNEY

ChildrenTHE KNOW-NONSENSE GUIDE TO MEASUREMENTS by Heidi Fiedler
by Heidi Fiedler
ChildrenTHE CASE OF THE STINKY STENCH by Josh Funk
by Josh Funk
ChildrenBERTIE WINGS IT! by Leslie Gorin
by Leslie Gorin

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenUTTERLY AMAZING EARTH by Dougal  Jerram
by Dougal Jerram
NonfictionTHE SEARCH FOR THE ELEMENTS by Isaac Asimov
by Isaac Asimov
ChildrenEARTH, FIRE, WATER, AIR by Mary Hoffman
by Mary Hoffman