ALTRUISM by Matthieu Ricard

ALTRUISM

The Power of Compassion to Change Yourself and the World
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

An overlong but vigorous gloss on the Dalai Lama’s famous remark, “My religion is kindness.”

Former geneticist and longtime Buddhist monk Ricard (Happiness, 2012, etc.) sets out to prove that true altruism exists, but he winds up exploring nearly the whole of human nature. His task is compounded by the Hobbesian mood of the age, when the individualistic mode is one of “irresponsible selfishness and rampant narcissism, to the detriment of the well-being of all.” However, altruism means many things to many people. Ricard generally agrees with researchers who hold that it is the motivation and not the “intensity” involved that counts: for it to matter, in other words, altruism is less the instinctual sacrifice of throwing oneself atop a hand grenade in a foxhole than the self-negation that comes, in one of the author’s examples, with abandoning a promising white-collar career in order to dig wells for impoverished villagers. One great virtue of this virtuous book is Ricard’s ability to poke holes in received wisdom. For example, he observes that while some abused children become abusers as adults, more often, they decide to “do the opposite of their parents when they have children.” Sometimes, the author is imprecise: cutting down on meat consumption won’t really “prevent 14% of deaths in the world,” since all of us die; perhaps he means death will be forestalled in that many cases. Elsewhere, Ricard ranges too far in quest of examples; his revisiting of the Holocaust-era extermination squads Christopher Browning writes about in Ordinary Men (1992) draws perhaps the wrong conclusion, for the opposite of that murder would not be guilty weeping but instead a policeman’s taking the place of a victim. Still, Ricard’s book, full of good behavior on the part of humans—and other animals—is of a piece with Steven Pinker’s The Better Angels of Our Nature (2011) in suggesting that we don’t have to be rotten.

Inspirational in all the right ways but a challenge to get through it all.

Pub Date: June 2nd, 2015
ISBN: 978-0-316-20824-6
Page count: 864pp
Publisher: Little, Brown
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: May 15th, 2015




MORE BY MATTHIEU RICARD

NonfictionA PLEA FOR THE ANIMALS by Matthieu Ricard
by Matthieu Ricard
NonfictionCARING ECONOMICS by Tania Singer
by Tania Singer
NonfictionTHE QUANTUM AND THE LOTUS by Matthieu Ricard
by Matthieu Ricard

MORE BY CHARLOTTE MANDELL

NonfictionJEAN COCTEAU by Claude Arnaud
by Claude Arnaud
FictionSTREET OF THIEVES by Mathias Énard
by Mathias Énard
NonfictionFACING THE TORTURER by François Bizot
by François Bizot

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionTHE PENGUIN AND THE LEVIATHAN by Yochai Benkler
by Yochai Benkler
NonfictionTHE SECRET OF OUR SUCCESS by Joseph Henrich
by Joseph Henrich
NonfictionINTO THE MAGIC SHOP by James R. Doty
by James R. Doty