TODAY YOU CAN'T PLAY by Pilar Serrano

TODAY YOU CAN'T PLAY

From the "Égalité" series
by ; illustrated by ; translated by &
Age Range: 4 - 8
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A bully causes a group of kids to find a solution to their playtime dilemma.

Ever since Emma’s arrival, Ana’s been isolated from her longtime friends, rumored about cruelly, and made to give up her lunches. Fearing the embarrassment of tattling, Ana suffers in silence—until her friends get the same kind of treatment and decide, one by one, to form their own play group. Despite threats, the group grows bigger each day until Emma is left alone and must sheepishly ask to join them all. This timely book about bullying and power dynamics unfortunately falls short on nuance and ends abruptly. The lesson from Spanish author and kindergarten teacher Serrano seems to be that kids should wait a bully out instead of getting an adult involved. And Emma herself is presented only as a frowning ball of anger and spite; it’s unclear what her motivations are and how, as a new kid in school, she was able to take control so easily. What both the English and simultaneously publishing Spanish versions of the book do get right, though, is the feeling of being trapped in an uncontrollable school power dynamic, illustrated with plenty of sweat and frowns. There’s the gulps, the tummy aches, the anxiety of feeling picked on and singled out. Emma presents white, Ana has brown skin, and the other kids are diverse.

Thin characterization and an unsatisfying ending make this one to miss. (Picture book. 4-8)

Pub Date: Aug. 27th, 2019
ISBN: 978-84-17123-46-8
Page count: 40pp
Publisher: nubeOCHO
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: May 15th, 2019




MORE BY BEN DAWLATLY

ChildrenADOPTING A DINOSAUR by José Carlos Andrés
by José Carlos Andrés
ChildrenI LOVE MY COLORFUL NAILS by Alicia Acosta
by Alicia Acosta

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

ChildrenLLAMA LLAMA AND THE BULLY GOAT by Anna Dewdney
by Anna Dewdney
ChildrenEDDIE THE BULLY by Henry Cole
by Henry Cole
ChildrenTHE PERFECT ANIMAL  by Raquel Díaz Reguera
by Raquel Díaz Reguera