MAYBE DYING IS LIKE BECOMING A BUTTERFLY by Pimm van Hest

MAYBE DYING IS LIKE BECOMING A BUTTERFLY

by ; illustrated by
Age Range: 4 - 8
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A young child and grandfather have a conversation about death.

When Grandpa suggests that a caterpillar might die if Christopher puts it in a jar, Christopher asks some questions about death, beginning with “Are you going to die, Grandpa?” The response: “Someday, sweetheart. But I hope not too soon.” The pair, both white, with big heads and small bodies in the cartoonlike illustrations, are walking and playing together in a park. Grandpa is stooped and walks with a cane; Christopher wears yellow boots. Their simple exchange covers a lot of philosophical ground. Grandpa acknowledges no one knows when they will die and that Christopher could die before him, but that the chance is small. Grandpa allows that “no one really knows” what happens after death, but he tells Christopher that some people think of heaven (“a place without sadness or war”), others of rebirth (“each time, you get wiser”), and others of “nothing” (“the same as before you were born”). The pair discusses the whys of death (“dying is part of life”), birth (“to learn all sorts of things”), and feelings of fear or comfort about dying. A concluding letter from Christopher to Grandpa, accompanied by an illustration of Christopher alone, offers the titular analogy about becoming a butterfly. Backmatter offers a brief comment and tips for discussion from a grief therapist.

Straightforward, gentle, useful, and engaging. (Picture book. 4-8)

Pub Date: Oct. 29th, 2019
ISBN: 978-1-60537-494-9
Page count: 32pp
Publisher: Clavis
Review Posted Online:
Kirkus Reviews Issue: Aug. 15th, 2019




MORE BY LISA BRANDENBURG

ChildrenTHAT'S FOR BABIES by Jackie Azúa Kramer
by Jackie Azúa Kramer
ChildrenIF YOU WANT TO FALL ASLEEP by Jackie Azúa Kramer
by Jackie Azúa Kramer