INTUITIVE/COUNTER INTUITIVE by Richard C. Johnson

INTUITIVE/COUNTER INTUITIVE

The Structure of Religion and Science
Email this review

KIRKUS REVIEW

A scientific critique of the rational limitations of intuition. 

Human consciousness, or the capacity for self-identification, provided mankind with a considerable evolutionary advantage. According to research chemist Johnson (Had Enough of God Yet?, 2017, etc.), self-awareness functioned as the basis for collaboration, communication, and ultimately, the formation of communities. However, the same consciousness raised questions that couldn’t be adequately answered about the nature of the material world. In the absence of systematic rational inquiry, writes the author, we filled in blanks with intuition; we conjured poetic narratives that accounted for our place in the world and provided a sense of security and purpose. Intuition is the source of religion, Johnson says, with its postulations of God and the immortal soul. The author argues that although intuition has practical and theoretical value—it allows us to quickly respond to danger and generate scientific hypotheses—it’s generally unreliable as an instrument for understanding the world. In fact, he says, it’s an endless fount of egregious falsehood, responsible for grotesque errors, ranging from racism to belief in the supernatural. Religion, he asserts, is the “junk of intuition,” as well as a source of violent, sectarian conflict, and it often operates contrary to human survival. In this book, Johnson predicts a future in which reason triumphs over intuition, and he offers a comprehensive neurochemical explanation of human consciousness. The author’s study is certainly wide-ranging, discussing the ideas of modern American philosopher Daniel Dennett, ancient Greek philosopher Thales of Miletus, and 19th-century French thinker Alexis de Tocqueville, to name a few. He presents his research on intuition rigorously and lucidly, and he intrepidly courts controversy. As a chemist, Johnson’s command of the pertinent scientific material is beyond reproach. However, he doesn’t address the long tradition of philosophical defenses of religion, even by those sympathetic to science; instead, he simply assumes all faiths are imaginative fictions. This intransigent dogmatism expresses itself repeatedly in the peremptory tone of his prose; at one point, for instance, he refers to theology as “absolutely worthless.”

An engaging appraisal of intuition, undermined by a cavalier dismissal of religion.

Pub Date: Nov. 15th, 2014
ISBN: 978-1-5006-1371-6
Page count: 234pp
Publisher: CreateSpace
Program: Kirkus Indie
Review Posted Online:




MORE BY RICHARD C. JOHNSON

IndieHAD ENOUGH OF GOD YET? by Richard C. Johnson
by Richard C. Johnson
IndieTHE HUMAN IDENTITY PROBLEM by Richard C. Johnson
by Richard C. Johnson

SIMILAR BOOKS SUGGESTED BY OUR CRITICS:

NonfictionLIVING FAITH by Jimmy Carter
by Jimmy Carter
NonfictionTHE RELIGION OF TECHNOLOGY by David F. Noble
by David F. Noble